SHARE
COPY LINK

ELECTIONS

Why pollsters are finding it hard to predict France’s snap elections

France's usually highly accurate political pollsters face a rare challenge in snap elections called by President Emmanuel Macron, struggling to predict the future shape of the Assemblée nationale.

Why pollsters are finding it hard to predict France's snap elections
Ballots in a ballot box at a polling station in Vanves, a suburb of Paris. Photo by Arnaud FINISTRE / AFP

France’s two-round voting system means that “the parliamentary election is usually difficult to begin with,” said an employee of one major survey firm.

But with new alliances and divisions within parties themselves, “we have no frame of reference now, the deck has been reshuffled,” she added, asking not to be named.

Some pollsters have had to reimburse staff for cancelled or delayed holidays to cope with the extra workload, the person said.

In the French electoral system, voters in the country’s 577 constituencies have a broad choice of candidates in the first round, which is set this time around for June 30th.

The two highest scorers plus any others who win backing from more than 12.5 percent of registered voters then proceed to the second round on July 7th.

If any candidate wins more than 50 percent in the first round then they win the seat without the need for a second round – this is rare in parliamentary elections but it does happen in some areas.

Voters often shift their support between the rounds, often at the behest of preferred candidates who fall short.

That makes prediction far more complex than the one-round proportional representation system in the June 9th European Parliament poll, when pollsters’ forecasts were all close to the final score.

“We’re losing a bit of sleep” ahead of the national ballot, said Jean-Daniel Levy, deputy director at Harris Interactive.

“The parliamentary election is the trickiest to grasp… it’s 577 polls and their local foibles,” he added.

Most opinion surveys are carried out online, with pollsters taking representative samples of over 1,000 people and asking where they live in a bid to smooth out constituency oddities — allowing them to extrapolate to the national level.

On the face of it, voters have a choice between three headline blocs: Macron’s centrists, the far-right Rassemblement National (RN) and the Nouveau Front Populaire (NFP) left-wing alliance.

An Ifop poll published Monday found that around 33 percent of people would vote RN in the first round, with the left at 28 percent and 18 percent for Macron’s bloc.

In fact, “it’s a lot more complicated,” said Mathieu Gallard, research director at Ipsos, pointing for example to the “totally chaotic” situation within the right-wing Les Républicains party (LR).

The LR has imploded, with party chief Eric Ciotti calling for an alliance with the far right while other figures want to maintain their independence or align with Macron.

Such dynamics mean national-level forecasts of votes and seats come with a clear buyer-beware warning.

It is almost impossible to predict this time how voters might behave between the two rounds.

“Mistakes are all but certain and we don’t know in which direction,” said Jerome Sainte-Marie, a former pollster standing for the RN in eastern France.

“The 2022 election showed us that seat projections before the first round are extremely shaky,” agreed Gallard. “It’s only after the first round that we’ll start to have a developing idea of the forces at play.”

Two years ago, surveys overestimated backing for Macron’s camp and underestimated the RN vote.

The party of Marine Le Pen was predicted to win 15 to 35 seats ahead of the first round, then up to 50 ahead of the second.

In the end, they brought in their largest-ever delegation of 89 MPs, overcoming a longstanding struggle for the far right to translate support into seats.

This year, “we’re in a totally unprecedented period, it’s almost impossible to understand what the political landscape will be in a week and a half,” said Hugo Touzet, a sociologist specialising in polls.

“If we do things seriously, the margin of error is plus or minus 80 MPs for each bloc, it’s huge,” he added.

Harris’s Levy told AFP that voters could return a “possible absolute or relative majority for the RN… repeating their voting behaviour at the European Parliament election”.

He sees “a little momentum” for the left that is still “far short of triggering a swing in parliament”.

On Macron’s side, there’s a “burst of mobilisation” that could prevent a re-run of their European rout.

Predictions made after the first-round results at 8pm on June 30th “could quickly go out of date” as voters update their preference before the second round on July 7th.

It could be that having “sent a message, voters don’t want all the power in the hands of the RN”, Levy said.

You can find all the latest election news HERE, or sign up here to receive by email our bi-weekly election breakdown.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

ELECTIONS

French parties in final push for votes ahead of snap elections

France's political forces are making a final bid on Friday for votes in crunch legislative elections that could see the far right take control of the government in a historic first.

French parties in final push for votes ahead of snap elections

The official campaigning period ends at midnight on Friday, followed by a day off on Saturday, during which political activity is forbidden ahead of voting on Sunday. Another week of campaigning will then lead up to the decisive second round on July 7th.

The far-right Rassemblement National (RN) is tipped to win the election, potentially giving the party the post of prime minister for the first time in its history in a tense “cohabitation” with centrist President Emmanuel Macron.

What’s at stake for foreigners in France if far-right Jordan Bardella becomes prime minister?

“Of course, I want to avoid the extremes, especially the far right, being able to win” the ballot, Macron’s Prime Minister Gabriel Attal told broadcaster BFMTV on Friday.

Opinion polls suggest his centrist alliance will come only third behind the RN and a broad but fragile left-wing coalition, the Nouveau Front Populaire (NFP).

The RN party chief, Jordan Bardella, 28, would have a chance to lead a government as prime minister.

But he has insisted he would do so only if his party wins an absolute majority – 289 of the 577 seats in the National Assembly – after the second round.

His party’s path to victory could be blocked if the left and centre-right join forces against the RN in the second round of voting.

Macron has caused controversy in the past two weeks by placing the left and the far-right on the same footing, labelling both “extremes”.

Speaking in Brussels on Thursday, however, he suggested that he would support moderate leftists against the far-right in the second round.

Macron also blasted the “arrogance” of the far right, which had “already allocated all the (government) jobs” before the election and questioned the president’s constitutional role as military commander in chief.

“Who are they to explain what the constitution should say?” he asked.

The RN’s three-time presidential candidate Marine Le Pen had ratcheted up tensions by saying that the president’s commander-in-chief title was purely “honorific”.

In the event of Macron having to share power with an RN-led government, “it’s the prime minister who holds the purse strings”, she warned.

In a televised debate on Thursday night, Attal said that Le Pen’s remarks sent a “very serious message for the security of France.”

Bardella sought to reassure voters about his party’s foreign policy, saying in the debate he would “not let Russian imperialism absorb an allied state like Ukraine”.

He said he was also opposed to sending longer range missiles to Ukraine that could hit Russian territory “and place France and the French in a situation of co-belligerence”.

“My compass is the interest of France and the French,” said Bardella.

Macron has insisted he will serve out the remainder of his second term until it expires in 2027, no matter which party emerges on top in the coming legislative contest.

Le Pen, whom opponents have long accused of having too cosy a relationship with the Kremlin, senses that this could be her best-ever chance to win the Elysée Palace after three previous attempts.

When he called the snap vote after a June 9th European Parliament election drubbing by the RN, Macron had hoped to present voters with a stark choice about whether to hand France to the far right.

An Opinionway poll of 1,058 people published Friday in business daily Les Echos predicted the RN would win 37 percent of the vote, the NFP 28 percent and Macron’s alliance just 20 percent.

In the second round, the RN “can not only envisage a relative majority, but we cannot exclude, far from it, an absolute majority,” Brice Teinturier, deputy director of competing pollster Ipsos, told AFP.

The televised debate, where Attal and Bardella were joined by Socialist leader Olivier Faure, was as ill-tempered as the first such session on Tuesday.

Attal charged that 100 RN candidates standing in the election had made “racist, anti-Semitic and homophobic comments.”

“Everything is false, utterly false,” responded Bardella, who also defended a controversial proposal to bar dual nationals from sensitive state posts.

Underscoring the stakes felt by many in France from ethnic minority backgrounds, French basketball superstar Victor Wembanyama said “for me it is important to take a distance from extremes, which are not the direction to take for a country like ours”.

He joins a host of other French sports, music and acting stars who have spoken out against the far right.

How to follow all the latest French election news in English this weekend

SHOW COMMENTS