SHARE
COPY LINK

INTEGRATION

New citizens should all speak Swedish: expert

Sweden needs to introduce language and cultural knowledge requirements for would-be Swedish citizens, according to one political scientist at an expert panel in Stockholm on Wednesday.

New citizens should all speak Swedish: expert

Following a poll of 4,600 people in Sweden about their views on Swedish citizenship, experts gathered at the government offices at Rosenbad to discuss the results and to find out how citizenship can be made more valuable for would-be Swedes.

The topic was discussed by a panel consisting of professors, lawyers, political scientists, as well as the researchers from Statistics Sweden (Statistiska centralbyrån, SCB) who carried out the poll.

Among these findings, a vast majority of people surveyed found it “very important” to have Swedish citizenship, the right to vote, as well as the right to live in and be protected by the country.

The survey is linked to government plans to review the role of citizenship in promoting integration.

Andreas Johansson Heinö, a political scientist and researcher at the University of Gothenburg, argued that according to his own research, Swedes want to see a set of requirements met before foreigners can be considered Swedish citizens.

When he polled 1,000 people, he discovered that 75 percent of respondents claimed to want would-be citizens to have a basic knowledge of the Swedish language.

“We need to introduce some sort of language and cultural knowledge requirements before people can become citizens,” he told The Local.

Johansson Heinö explained that his survey revealed that a majority of people agreed that potential Swedes ought to have a basic knowledge of Swedish history too, and should agree with Swedish values.

“I totally agree with the precept that we need to strengthen the value of citizenship in Sweden, because it’s a valuable asset for equality in a diverse society,” he explained.

“The problem is that even though they become citizens; they’re still not conforming,” he said.

“But this is more of a problem for the Swedish majority.”

Furthermore, Johansson Heinö argued that it’s impossible for a newcomer to become Swedish if Swedishness is defined by ethnicity, language, religion and skin colour.

Other factors, however, are genuinely important, he argued.

“I argue that we need a common language to be able to have a society together, we need some basic knowledge about our history, our culture, and how society works,” he said.

Meanwhile, Pakistan-born Qaisar Mahmood, a manager at the Swedish National Heritage Board (Riksantikvarieämbetet), explained that getting Swedish citizenship should be seen as a valuable opportunity to connect.

“Whether you are in a football team or at work, the sense of belonging is important for human beings,” he told The Local.

“But formalities are not enough. If you play football, it may be important to be seen as a team mate and to cherish the sense of belonging. You can’t say that you play for one team and belong to another, it doesn’t work like that.”

“It’s like that with countries, having a sense of [being in] a collective with people living in states sharing common laws and social security. It should be easier to be a citizen and this is important.”

However, Mahmood explained that physical appearance plays a big part in how people with different backgrounds are judged in Sweden.

“The idea of belonging to the state is still based on ethnicity, and this is often interpreted by how you look. I think that’s one of the reasons people from other northern countries don’t feel the same urge as someone who looks like me to be part of the Swedishness.”

Meanwhile, Johansson Heinö, whose book Gillar Vi Olika was published in September and tackles similar issues, explained that his ambition was more about finding the answers, not giving them.

“My goal is to improve the quality of the debate of the integration into Sweden,” he said.

“If we really want to become a multicultural society we need to confront our own self-image.”

Following the discussion, the panel will present its comprehensive findings to the government by April 1st next year.

Oliver Gee

Follow Oliver on Twitter here

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

RESIDENCY PERMITS

FACT CHECK: Can you get a residency permit if you buy property in Sweden?

There have been several reports of foreigners who bought Swedish property after they were falsely made to believe that it would speed up their process towards a Swedish residency permit. But what do the rules actually say?

FACT CHECK: Can you get a residency permit if you buy property in Sweden?

I’ve never been told buying property in Sweden will give me a residence permit. Is this really a thing?

The short answer is a firm no, but despite this there has been a series of incidents of non-EU foreigners who were allegedly tricked into buying property in Sweden before moving, believing that owning property would make them eligible for a Swedish residence permit.

What’s the story? 

These incidents most recently grabbed headlines in June 2024, when public broadcaster SVT reported that a number of properties in Sweden had been sold to buyers in the Middle East well over market price, after the buyers were led to believe it would help them gain residence permits. The properties are all linked to businessman Kadry El Naggar, who runs the company Sweden for Investment.

As far back as 2013, SVT reported that another company owned by El Naggar, Swedish Connections, at the time told buyers in Egypt that buying property in Sweden would help speed up the process of getting a residence permit or even Swedish citizenship.

El Naggar has never been convicted of any crimes, but he has been sued by two previous buyers. In one of the cases, the purchase was cancelled, and the other buyer won their court case. He denied to SVT that his company offers its services under false pretence.

“I buy old houses and sell them on. I don’t sell permanent residency permits. That’s clear if you look at our sites,” he told SVT.

A note on his website reads “we do not issue visas or guarantee any residence permits as these are determined individually by the Swedish Migration Board”. But SVT reports that in several social media posts, El Naggar falsely claims that all foreigners need to get a Swedish residency permit is a bank statement showing a balance of at least 20,000 dollars (210,660 kronor), as well as a company and property.

How many properties have they sold?

According to SVT, there are 50 properties up and down the country linked to El Naggar, his wife or their company, with 32 of those in Norrland. Thirty-six properties currently have one or more foreign owners, with a total of 53 owners registered as living outside of Sweden.

The broadcaster also linked 37 different Sweden-registered companies to these owners, who are registered as living in a number of different countries, including Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and Palestine.

Many of the properties are in relatively bad condition, sold via executive auction through the Swedish Enforcement Authority (Kronofogden).

One pharmacist from Egypt told SVT he had paid 188,000 kronor for a home in the village of Undrom outside Sollefteå in northern Sweden, with the dream of giving his children a better life, after Facebook adverts promised that he could get residency through buying a property.

He hasn’t even been able to visit his house in Undrom due to the cost of travelling to Sweden from Saudi Arabia, where he lives. 

He told SVT he had been warned by someone else who had been in a similar situation just before he was due to make the final payment on the home, and he then demanded to cancel the purchase, but the company refused. He has now hired lawyers in Egypt and Sweden.

“We’ve seen that this method has been ongoing for a while,” Migration Agency official Anette Bäcklund told SVT.

“And all of those people who have applied for a residence permit from us have had their applications denied. You need to follow certain rules to qualify for a residence permit, and that hasn’t been the case in these cases.”

How do I move to Sweden as an entrepreneur or investor?

It is possible to get a temporary residence permit as a self-employed person in Sweden, and permit holders who can support themselves and their families are eligible for permanent residency after just two years, but this requires more than just having a high enough bank balance, registering a company in Sweden and owning a property.

According to the Migration Agency, self-employed people must meet the following requirements in order to be granted a two-year residence permit:

  • hold a valid passport
  • show you have good experience of your industry and previous experience of running your own company
  • show you have relevant knowledge of Swedish or English. For example, if you have contact with a number of suppliers or customers in Sweden, you need to be able to speak Swedish to a very high level
  • prove that you are in charge of running the company and that you have decisive influence for it
  • prove that you have enough money to support yourself and any family accompanying you (200,000 kronor for you, 100,000 kronor for an accompanying partner or spouse and 50,000 kronor for each accompanying child)
  • show a credible foundation for your budget
  • show that you have built a network of customers or other business network
  • pay a fee in most cases (equal to the fee for a work permit)

The Migration Agency will then assess your business plans to determine whether or not you should be granted a permit. There is no requirement for applicants to own a property in Sweden.

If you are granted a two-year permit and want to apply for permanent residency once it runs out, there are further requirements. You will need to prove that you are still running the company, are complying with good accounting practices and have all the necessary permits for the business, among other things, at the time you renew your permit. 

Permanent residency applicants need to prove that they and their family have been living in “reasonable” housing conditions, but there is no stipulation that they must own this home.

SHOW COMMENTS