SHARE
COPY LINK
BREXIT

BRITAIN

British expats in France face years of limbo: Brexit report

The British government’s first official report into the impact of a future Brexit has revealed that the rights of British expats in France and other parts of the EU will no longer be guaranteed.

British expats in France face years of limbo: Brexit report
Photo: Josh Hallett/Flickr

A report by the cabinet office has backed up what many British expats in France are deeply concerned about: a Brexit will mean years of uncertainty and the loss of rights.

The official report, the first by the government into how a Brexit would unfold in practice, concluded it would take the UK ten years to extricate itself from the EU and renegotiate new treaties with member states and other nations.

The study says the doubt will negatively impact on “financial markets, investment and the value of the pound”.

But more significantly, at least for the some 300,000 British expats in France and the 2.2 million thought to be living in the EU, it will plunge their lives into years of insecurity.

“A vote to leave the EU would be the start, not the end of a process. It could lead up to a decade or more of uncertainty,” the civil servants who wrote the report concluded.

If the UK public vote to leave the EU, the government would have to trigger “Article 50” of the Lisbon Treaty, which would begin the process of withdrawal and give the UK two years to renegotiate ties with Brussels.

But the government report said any renegotiation would likely take far longer as European countries try to take advantage of any new treaty with Britain.

Top of the list for issues that would need to be resolved in the case of a Brexit would be access for UK citizens to the European health insurance card.

(Photo: AFP)

British expats face 'complete limbo'

The British government’s Europe Minister David Lidlington carried similar warnings saying on Sunday that “everything we take for granted about access to the single market” would be thrown into doubt.

“Trade deals between the EU and other countries and bilateral trade deals of any type normally take six, seven, eight years and counting,” said David Lidlington.

“Everything we take for granted about access to the single market – trade taking place without customs checks or paperwork at national frontiers, the right of British citizens to go and live in Spain or France – those would all be up in the air. It is massive. It is massive what is at risk.”

The minister told the Observer newspaper that Brits in France and elsewhere would be in “complete limbo”.

In a letter to The Local France, George Peretz QC, an expert on EU law, pointed out what that “limbo” would mean in reality.

Peretz said a Brexit would inevitably see “UK citizens in France lose all the EU rights they currently enjoy”.

“It’s not just the loss of the right to use the French state health services. It goes well beyond that,” said Peretz.

“UK citizens would lose their EU law rights to work, to set up a business, to buy property, to bring family to live with them, not to be deported for trivial offences and so on. France might let them do all those things. But that would be entirely up to France.”

Those in favour of a Brexit however have dismissed all talk of uncertainty and loss of rights as pure fear mongering. They counter that any adverse impact caused by the uncertainty will be offset by the advantages of having independence from Europe. 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

BRITS IN FRANCE

Thousands of Brits still move to France despite post-Brexit paperwork

Moving to France has become a lot more complicated for Brits since Brexit, but latest French immigration data shows that thousands of them still move here.

Thousands of Brits still move to France despite post-Brexit paperwork

The days of EU freedom of movement are over for UK nationals (unless they also have the passport of an EU country) and now moving to France requires first getting a visa and then requesting a carte de séjour residency card once here.

Getting a visa comes with a raft of requirements including proof of being able to be financially self-sufficient via either a job, a pension or savings.

READ MORE: EXPLAINED: How to apply for a visa to France

However it seems that these requirements are not putting off everyone – and around 9,000 Brits made the move to France in 2023.

French statistics

The French interior ministry has published its provisional immigration data for 2023, which provides the first clear post-Brexit picture of how many Brits move to France.

Although the Brexit transition period ended at the end of 2020, figures on residency cards from 2021 and 2022 include British long-term residents in France being issued with a residency card under the Brexit Withdrawal Agreement.

The figures from 2023 therefore provide the first clear indication of how many Brits move to France since Brexit.

And thousands did – 9,261 UK nationals were issued with a first-time carte de séjour residency card in 2023. Although this number may include a small number of family members of British residents who were resident before Brexit, the great majority of these are people moving to France for the first time.

READ MORE: 10 things to do before moving to France

It is not possible to compare this with pre-Brexit patterns since before the UK left the EU Brits were not required to get a visa or residency card to live in France, and there is therefore no comparable data.

How many Brits live in France now?

The interior ministry data does, however, give an idea of the total number of Brits living in France – prior to Brexit, this was difficult to estimate due to EU freedom of movement. 

In 2023, French authorities noted that there were 166,314 Brits holding residency cards in France, a 2.5 percent increase from 2022, when there were 161,194.

The real figure is probably slightly higher because it does not include Brits who have dual nationality with an EU country – eg British-Irish or British-French dual nationals – since they are not required to have a residency card. 

In 2020, a study by the French national statistics body, INSEE used pre-Brexit data and estimated that there were 148,000 Britons in France. This also found that a large number of Brits in France were in western and south-west France, particularly in départements of Charente, Dordogne and Haute-Vienne.

READ MORE: Which part of south-west France is the top ‘dream destination’ to move to?

Brits becoming French

In 2023, 1,522 Brits gained French nationality, with 767 going via décret (by residency) while another 755 gained French nationality via déclaration, the category for those who are either married to a French person or can prove family ties (eg parent of a French child).

In comparison, in 2022, 2,206 Brits became French, and in 2019, 3,557 did.

Acquiring French citizenship is a long process – the application takes an average of between 18 months and two years, while those applying through residency need to have lived in France for five years (cut to two years if they have completed higher education in France).

The post Brexit period saw a spike in Brits applying to become French – many had lived in France for many years but had never considered it necessary before since they already had the right to live in France.

What Brits do in France

Unfortunately, the data did not specify the types of residency cards given to Brits in 2023. 

However, Eurostat data from 2022 did break down first time residency permits into four categories; work, study, family reunification or ‘other’ – which includes retirees and others who don’t intend to work or study in France.

READ MORE: ‘Not all gin-swilling pensioners’ – What are Brits in France really doing?

While their data differs slightly form the interior ministry numbers, they found that a little under half (3,182 out of 7,927) of first-time residency cards for Brits were work-related.

After that, students came in second place, with 1,901 came to study in 2022.

France has been working hard to market itself as an international study destination and around 400,000 foreign students come here each year. It is the fourth most popular country for foreign students – and the top non-English speaking country.

Although Brexit has made studying in France more complicated for British students, the fact that French is still widely taught in British schools makes it a natural destination for those who want to study abroad.

READ MORE: How easy is it to move to France if you don’t speak French?

The third biggest group of Brits was the ‘other’ category which includes retirees and had 1,760 people. Meanwhile, 1,084 people came via family reunification – ie joining a spouse, partner or parents already resident in France, according to Eurostat.

How do Brits compare overall?

In comparison to general immigration data, Brits are somewhat different and are more likely to move to France to work than to study.

In 2023, the interior ministry data for all non-EU nationals moving to France showed that the largest group were students. After that, the second largest category was ‘family’ related residency cards, and the third was work-related.

Brits reverse that trend being most likely to move to France to work.

As for the number of Brits moving to France, there are fewer Britons coming here than Americans. In 2023, 12,153 Americans were issued a first-time residency card – although that number includes a significant number of students doing a study abroad programme who don’t actually intend to make France their home.

Brits come in 10th place for the largest nationality represented in new residency cards issued, behind Indians who made up 9,819 first-time cartes de séjour. Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, China and the United States were the top five (in order).

SHOW COMMENTS