SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

CREDIT RATING

Schufa explained: How to avoid the ‘catch 22’ in Germany’s credit rating system

The process of obtaining a Schufa, which is needed for rental agreements, can be confusing and frustrating. We give you the low down on the German credit history system.

Schufa explained: How to avoid the 'catch 22' in Germany's credit rating system
Image: DPA

Of the many documents, numbers and permissions to obtain once moving to Germany, perhaps the most frustrating is the Schufa

In order to enter into most contracts – such as a rental agreement – the person or business you’re contracting with is likely to demand a Schufa certificate – a piece of paper which demonstrates your clear (or not so clear) credit record. 

The problem is getting a credit rating without having entered into a lease, contract or loan arrangement before, meaning that for new arrivals the Schufa can create a ‘catch 22’ situation. 

The system itself can also be confusing in the way it tallies the points. A person who has never missed a payment and should have a spotless credit score will never get a 100 percent rating, no matter how ‘in the black’ they are. 

While even debt experts find the process a little murky at times, we’ve broken down what you need to know about the Schufa system – and more importantly how to get that valuable piece of paper. 

READ ALSO: How one piece of paper holds the key to your future in Germany

Schufa (Shoo-Fa)

Dealing with bureaucracy on a regular basis proves that ‘German efficiency’ is but a myth, but at least the Germans are relatively efficient with their abbreviations.

Schufa is short for Schutzgemeinschaft für Allgemeine Kreditsicherung, which translates loosely to Protection Organization for General Credit Safety. 

And although it may not feel that way when your low Schufa score prevents you from renting a flat or opening up a line of credit, the goal of the organisation is to help – specifically to protect people from themselves and getting into too much debt.

Indeed, while German efficiency may be a myth, Germany’s almost pathological distaste for debt is not. 

What is a Schufa?

When people in Germany speak about getting ‘a Schufa’, they usually are referring to the document which confirms their credit status. It takes into account your previous payment behaviour – i.e. if you’ve missed payments or been in debt before – and then provides you with a percentage score. 

The more marks against your name, the lower the percentage is going to be. As the percentage gets lower, there are more restrictions on the types of contracts and debt arrangements you can get into. 

For instance, loans may come at a higher interest rate, or deposits may need to be higher.  

Image: DPA

A catch 22?

From the outset, getting a Schufa can seem like a catch 22. Technically speaking, in order to get one you’ll need an address. But if you’re in the process of getting an address, you’ll need a Schufa. 

Fortunately, as soon as you register in Germany, a credit rating will automatically be created for you. This means that it exists even if you don’t know about it and if you haven’t rented anything yet. 

There are a few different ways to get a Schufa, with the preferred one dependent on your budget and your time constraints. You are entitled to one free copy of your Schufa per year. 

SEE ALSO: ‘Know your rights’: The advice you need about renting in Germany

This can be done online, however it will take its time to get to you. We don’t know this for sure, but it certainly appears that Schufa Holding AG make this option a little more difficult – and a lot slower – as it doesn’t make them any money.

Just judging by how difficult it is to find on the website, we think this theory holds true. 

If you’re in a rush, you can order online at a cost of between €25 and €30. You’ll be provided with a soft copy which you can print immediately. 

There are also a range of other options which let you sign up and pay a monthly amount, although there appear to be few benefits to this unless you expect that your credit rating will fluctuate regularly (in which case you’ve probably got bigger fish to fry). 

The final option is to visit a bank and pay for them to print it out for you. This is immediate and will cost roughly the same as that above but will be printed on fancy bank paper. In order to do this you’ll need a German ID, or at least a passport and a proof of permission to live in Germany (if you’re from outside the EU).

Most banks will provide this service (because they make money off it) and you don’t need to have an account with them to do so. We know it works at Postbank, Volksbank and Deutsche Bank, with most of the others offering the same service.

READ ALSO: The ins and outs of buying property in Germany

Keep it 100

The points-scoring process for a Schufa is notoriously opaque. It has attracted criticism from NGOs and media sources for its lack of transparency. As we discussed here, movements have been growing to create an open and clearer system.

Advocates of the current system however argue that there is a need for secrecy, given the sensitive nature of the information – and the impact it may have on someone’s life. Either way, campaigns to alter the system are set to continue. 

One of the central mysteries of the system is the way in which the score is actually awarded. For instance, even for those who have paid every bill on time, they will not have a score of 100 percent.

Indeed, it’s not uncommon to have a score in the middle of the 90s even if you’ve got a spotless credit history. 

While this may be frustrating for those trying their best to ‘keep it 100’, fortunately all lenders and landlords are aware of this bizarre quirk, meaning they are not going to penalise you when your score isn’t three figures.

Member comments

  1. I signed on for 2 years with T-Mobile (mobile phone account), paid the first month, after which & to my surprise I received my “Schufa” that declared that I had always paid my debts (which was technically true) (I still pay my monthly phone bill but for Schufa that first month was enough to give me a clean sheet – go figure!) .

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

RENTING

How a German ‘Mieterverein’ can help you reduce your rent

If you're renting in Germany, you may have heard about a tenants' association - or Mieterverein. But you may not be aware that joining one could help save you money in the long run.

How a German 'Mieterverein' can help you reduce your rent

There’s a truism that applies to many areas of life in Germany: there are plenty of rules and legal protections, but the vast majority of people don’t know them.

This feels particularly real when it comes to the world of renters’ rights. As a nation that generally prefers to rent than to buy, Germany has a huge range of in-built protections for tenants – but that doesn’t always stop landlords from bending the rules. 

The best way to make sure you’re getting a fair deal is to try and get familiar with your rights, or enlist the help of somebody who knows them inside-out.

That’s where the concept of the Mieterverein, or tenants’ association, comes in. These member-only organisations are there to advocate for the rights of tenants, keeping illegally high rents and other dodgy practices in check for renters in Germany. 

These types of associations can be a life-saver for foreigners who may struggle with the German language and German law, and could even help you save money in the long run. 

What is a Mieterverein?

A Mieterverein, or tenants’ association, is exactly what it sounds like: an organisation that stands up for the rights of tenants. It works by offering affordable memberships for renters – usually costing somewhere between €50 and €100 per year – which is then used to provide legal advice and representation, as well as advocacy and lobbying work. 

Ultimately, the idea is about strength in numbers. Instead of a single tenant taking on a big landlord like Vonovia or Deutsche Wohnen, a collective approach gives renters both more bargaining power and more resources.

Following this principle, many of the regional Mietervereine have clubbed together to create tenants’ associations in their state, which ultimately belong to the Germany-wide umbrella association, the Deutscher Mieterbund (DMB).

There are 320 associations currently active in the DMB, with the largest being the Berliner Mieterverein with more than 190,000 members. This is followed by Hamburg, with 78,000 members, and Munich, with 63,000. 

READ ALSO: How foreign residents in Germany are winning rent reductions

Members rely on tenants’ associations to assist with anything to do with Germany’s tenancy law. That means poring over rental contracts, ironing out difficulties with landlords, challenging rent increases or overly high rents, and fighting unfair or illegal evictions.

Of course, one of the most compelling reasons to join is to keep high rents in check – and find out if you could be eligible for a reduction. 

How can a Mieterverein help lower my rent?

Though it may not always feel like it, the vast majority of areas with a tight housing situation in Germany are subject to fairly stringent rental controls, known as the Mietpreisbremse.

These controls were mandated in a 2015 law that has recently been extended to 2029. Though there are some loopholes, the rules generally dictate that cold rents should be no more than 10 percent above the average rent for comparable properties in the same neighbourhood.

READ ALSO: German rent brake to be extended until 2029: What you need to know

The ways for calculating this are complicated but all you really need to know is that they are based on something called the Mietspiegel: a huge table charting the average rent prices based on factors like a property’s size, location, age and facilities. 

Berlin prenzlauer Berg

Flats in the Berlin district of Prenzlauer Berg. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Monika Skolimowska

One service tenants’ associations can offer is to compare your rent against the Mietspiegel to see if you’re being charged too much. 

To do this, they’ll look at your contract and ask you a series of questions about your rental property. If it turns out the rent is illegally high, Mieterverein lawyers can help you draft a letter to officially challenge your rent and ask for it to be reduced.

Some tenants’ associations also offer legal protection insurance (Rechtsschutzversicherung) as part of their memberships, which can help you deal with any issues that may arise with the landlord later on. 

What about annual rent increases?

In most cases, these can be disputed as well. Under the Mietpreisbremse rules, rents can be raised by a maximum of 20 percent in the space of three years. This can be good grounds to challenge a big annual increase in rent – but it isn’t the only way. 

The legal representatives at your local Mieterverein will be able to help you dispute increases in rent, as long as you don’t agree to these increases straight away.

Once again, the increases may be based on a shaky foundation of illegally high rents to start with, so it’s always worth getting everything checked over in full by a qualified lawyer.

It’s also worth keeping an eye on any issues with your apartment, such as broken fixtures and fittings, because these can be grounds for a rent reduction until the problem is fixed.

READ ALSO: How to get a rent reduction for problems in your German flat

Advisors at the Mietervereine will not only be able to tell you what are grounds for a Mietminderung (temporary rent reduction), but also how much you could be entitled to. 

SHOW COMMENTS