SHARE
COPY LINK

EUROPEAN UNION

EU urges ‘flexibility’ to seal Swiss cooperation deal

European Union chief Ursula von der Leyen called for "flexibility" as Swiss President Guy Parmelin visited Brussels on Friday for talks aimed at breaking the logjam over a long-delayed cooperation agreement.

guy-parmelin-brussels
Swiss President Guy Parmelin holds a press conference with the European Commission president during a meeting at the European Commission building in Brussels on April 23, 2021. François WALSCHAERTS / AFP / POOL

Brussels has made no secret of its growing impatience to nail down a “framework agreement” to unify a patchwork of accords with Bern, 13 years in the making.

“In a negotiation, the final metres are the most difficult,” European Commission president von der Leyen said at the start of the meeting.

“I do, however, think that it should be possible to find compromises and conclude our institutional framework agreement. We just need some flexibility on both sides.”

For the EU, negotiations on the deal concluded in 2018 – but the Swiss have continued to press for changes and have so far balked at signing.

The agreement would rejig five major agreements within 120 bilateral accords that govern non-EU member Switzerland’s relations with the bloc.

READ ALSO: ‘Swiss autonomy’: Does Switzerland need a better agreement with the EU?

Among other points, they touch on access to the single market and fine-tuning applicable Swiss and EU laws.

“Over the past months, our chief negotiators have conducted very intense negotiations on the items which remain outstanding,” Swiss President Guy Parmelin said.

“These discussions have been far from easy, however, but I think I can say that both sides have shown their commitment to make a success of these negotiations today.”

Fears abound that failing to secure the framework deal could jeopardise Switzerland’s relationship with its largest trading partner at a time when more than half of all Swiss exports go to the bloc, which all but surrounds the landlocked country.

‘Prerequisite’ for good EU-Swiss relations

Declarations that the deal was nearly dead have multiplied in recent months.

Some hope of a comeback was restored with a report in Switzerland’s Blick newspaper this week suggesting Bern would offer easier access to Swiss residence permits for people from newer EU member states in eastern Europe in exchange for a fresh revision of the deal.

READ ALSO: EXPLAINED: What non-EU nationals (including Britons) need to know about Swiss work permits?

While not really comparable to Brexit, Switzerland would face significant consequences if the framework agreement fell through.

Since 2008, the EU has insisted Switzerland must sign the agreement before concluding any new bilateral deals.

Brussels reiterated that position last week, with European Commission spokesman Eric Mamer insisting the agreement was “necessary to develop good relations between the European Union and Switzerland”.

“It is a prerequisite for these relations to continue,” he said.

Switzerland’s leader met von der Leyen with this warning in mind, while facing pressure from the economic and financial sectors to save the deal – and demands from opponents to not cave in to the EU.

Parmelin is from the populist right-wing Swiss People’s Party. Switzerland’s largest political party has for years led efforts to resist closer ties with the EU, and has described the framework agreement as a “Diktat from Brussels”.

There are also calls for the agreement to be put to a referendum, in keeping with the direct democracy system in Switzerland.

The overarching accord would require revising five existing bilateral agreements on free movement, industrial standards, agriculture, air and land transport – and the creation of a joint arbitration court that could enable compensation for breaches.

It would also require the creation of an arbitration court to settle differences between the two sides.

Bern has continued to ask for clarifications on three points: Swiss wage protection, state subsidies and a directive that would give EU citizens in Switzerland the same right to social security as Swiss citizens.

So far, Brussels has said it is willing to provide clarifications on certain points, but has ruled out any renegotiations.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

IMMIGRATION

Why is Switzerland spending 300 million francs to protect Schengen borders?

From August 1st, 2024, Switzerland will contribute financially to the European effort to strengthen the protection of the Schengen area’s external borders.

Why is Switzerland spending 300 million francs to protect Schengen borders?

Though Switzerland is not a member of the EU, it does belong to the Schengen area — not only benefitting from the access to Europe’s borderless zone, but also participating in its funding.

Financial support is especially needed in Schengen countries with particularly extensive land and sea borders or major international airports on their territories, because they bear a heavy financial burden of securing the zone’s external borders, for the benefit of all the other members.

How will Switzerland’s 300-million-franc contribution be used?

Over the period of next seven years, it will go toward the programme called Instrument for Financial Support for Border Management and Visa Policy (BMVl), which is part of the fund that ensures efficient management of EU’s borders.

The EU already allocated 6.24 billion euros to the BMVI for a seven-year period, and 300 million francs is Switzerland’s share.

Specifically, those funds will be used towards improving external border controls, investing in common large-scale IT systems in the area of borders management and visa policy, funding infrastructure and equipment, and deployment of immigration liaison officers, among other tasks.

Why is Switzerland contributing 300 million francs?

The BMVl’s goal is to “improve the protection of the external borders of the Schengen area and, therefore, to increase the effectiveness of border controls and prevent illegal immigration,” the Federal Council said

This, along with effective and integrated management of the external borders “is also in Switzerland’s interest.”

Also, Switzerland will likely receive grants from the BMVl of around 50 million francs to be allocated mainly to the establishment of new EU information systems (EES Entry and Exit System, and European Travel Information and Authorization System ETIAS) on its territory.

Furthermore, it is planned to use part of these resources to finance the expansion of the border control infrastructure at Zurich Airport.

Benefits for Switzerland

There is no doubt that Swiss citizens benefit greatly from access to the Schengen zone.

Simply put, it allows anyone who is in Switzerland legally to enjoy hassle-free travel to and from the 26 other Schengen states, visa time limits permitting.

Travellers arriving into Switzerland for the first time from a non-Schengen state like the UK or the US will have to queue up to have their passports checked, but after that they can move freely.

That means Swiss citizens, EU nationals, non-EU international residents in Switzerland, tourists, exchange students or people travelling for business can travel on to another Schengen member state, perhaps neighbouring France or Germany by car or train, without having to show their passports. (Although occasionally checks are brought back.) 

That is a definite ‘plus’ for anyone who travels within Europe. Due to Switzerland having so many land borders with other Schengen countries it would have been hugely problematic not to join.
 

SHOW COMMENTS