SHARE
COPY LINK

ENVIRONMENT

‘Dead fish everywhere’ in German-Polish river after feared chemical waste dump

Thousands of fish have washed up dead on the Oder river running through Germany and Poland, sparking warnings of an environmental disaster as residents are urged to stay away from the water.

A woman takes pictures of dead fish on the banks of the river Oder in Schwedt, eastern Germany, on August 12th, 2022, after a massive fish kill was discovered in the river close to the border with Poland.
A woman takes pictures of dead fish on the banks of the river Oder in Schwedt, eastern Germany, on August 12th, 2022, after a massive fish kill was discovered in the river close to the border with Poland. Photo by Odd ANDERSEN / AFP
The fish floating by the German banks near the eastern town of Schwedt are believed to have washed upstream from Poland where first reports of mass fish deaths were made by locals and anglers as early as on 28th July.
 
German officials accused Polish authorities of failing to inform them about the deaths, and were taken by surprise when the wave of lifeless fish came floating into view.
 
In Poland, the government has also come under heavy criticism for failing to take swift action.
 
Almost two weeks after the first dead fish appeared floating by Polish villages, Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki said on Friday that “everyone had initially thought that it was a local problem”.
 
But he admitted that the “scale of the disaster is very large, sufficiently large to say that the Oder will need years to recover its natural state.”
 
“Probably enormous quantities of chemical waste was dumped into the river in full knowledge of the risk and consequences,” added the Polish leader, as German Environment Minister Steffi Lemke urged a comprehensive probe into what she called a brewing “environmental disaster”.
 
‘Atypical’
 
Standing by the riverbank, Michael Tautenhahn, deputy chief of Germany’s Lower Oder Valley National Park, looked in dismay at the river on the German-Polish border.
 
“We are standing on the German side — we have dead fish everywhere,” he told AFP.
 
 
“I am deeply shocked… I have the feeling that I’m seeing decades of work lying in ruins here. I see our livelihood, the water — that’s our life,” he said, noting that it’s not just fish that have died, but also mussels and likely countless other water creatures. “It’s just the tip of the iceberg.”
 

Dead fish are pictured on the banks of the river Oder in Schwedt, eastern Germany on August 12th, 2022.

Dead fish are pictured on the banks of the river Oder in Schwedt, eastern Germany on August 12th, 2022. Photo by Odd ANDERSEN / AFP
 
The Oder has over the last years been known as a relatively clean river, and 40 domestic species of fish make their home in the waterway.
 
But now, lifeless fish — some as small as a few centimetres, others reaching 30-40 cm — can be seen across the river. Occasionally, those still struggling to pull through can be seen flipping up in the water, seemingly gasping for air.
 
Officials believe that the fish are likely to have been poisoned.
 
“This fish death is atypical,” said Axel Vogel, environment minister for Brandenburg state, estimating that “undoubtedly tonnes” of fish have died.
 
Fish death is often caused by the distortion of oxygen levels when water levels are too low, he explained.
 
“But we have completely different test results, namely that we have had increased oxygen level in the river for several days, and that indicates that a foreign substance has been introduced that has led to this,” he said.
 
Tests are ongoing in Germany to establish the substance that may have led to the deaths.
 
Early reports had suggested indications of extremely high levels of mercury. But another batch of preliminary results released on Friday evening showed unusually high levels of salt.
 
Authorities said they were inconclusive, and that further test results on heavy metals and mercury were pending.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

READER QUESTION

Where can I dispose my old electronics in Germany?

Did you know that throwing out old electronics in the regular mixed trash is illegal in Germany? Here are the easiest ways to safely and legally dispose of e-waste in Germany.

Where can I dispose my old electronics in Germany?

Electronic waste or e-waste (Elektroschrott or E-Müll) is one of those not-so-sexy aspects of modern life. 

We collect a wide assortment of personal electronics in our day to day lives – from smartphones to hair dryers to toaster ovens – and eventually they break or go unused, and end up hidden away in a dark corner in our closets or cellars.

According to Germany’s statistical office (Destatis), German residents produce more e-waste per capita than the European average – 12.5 kilograms per person per year in Germany as opposed to 10.5 kilograms across Europe.

What this amounts to practically is you having three dead phones and a nest of old chargers in the back of an old desk drawer, or perhaps an old mini-fridge to dispose of in your cellar.

Learning to sort and dispose of your waste properly in Germany is a notoriously tricky task for many newcomers, and putting electronics in the regular trash or recycling bins is illegal in Germany. Therefore you may find yourself with an armful of dead gadgets asking, “How do I get rid of these?”

READ ALSO: EXPLAINED – The complete guide to recycling in Germany

Fortunately, disposing of most small household electronics in Germany can be surprisingly easy. 

Where can I dispose of my old smartphone?

In most cases, the easiest place to dispose of personal electronics is your nearest supermarket.

Since July 2022 supermarkets and discount retailers with a store size of 800 square metres or more are required to collect small electrical appliances free of charge. 

This generally applies to Germany’s main supermarket chains like Rewe, Penny, Lidl and Aldi. It also applies to electronics stores like MediaMarkt and Saturn.

These stores are required to accept electronics with an edge length up to 25 centimetres, such as; razors, electric toothbrushes, chargers, small toasters or smartphones. 

Note that these stores are only be required to accept up to three items at a time, so if you have a stockpile of electronics to dispose of, you may have to break them up in separate trips.

old phones

A pile of outdated phones seen at a drop-off collection point. Photo: picture alliance / dpa | Maurizio Gambarini

Smaller items like dead batteries or lightbulbs can often be dropped off at these locations as well. Just ask the staff where they are gathered.

If your local market is smaller than 800 square metres, you may need to try elsewhere. 

Additionally, there have been reports of markets not fulfilling their collection requirements.

For example, the Cologne Regional Court fined an Aldi Nord store in North Rhine-Westphalia after it failed to take three electronic items from a customer who had tried to drop them off.

The German environmental non-profit Deutsche Umwelthilfe (DUH) had tested electronics drop-offs at Aldi and other retailer locations and found some deficiencies. 

In this case, Aldi suggested that the employee involved had no knowledge of the regulation and was sentenced to pay a meagre fine of €386.20. But in more severe cases stores could theoretically face fines up to €250,000 for failing to fulfil their collection duties.

What about bulkier items?

Supermarkets and electronics retailers are not responsible for collecting bulkier items.

An exception is made when you are buying a new comparable appliance to replace an old one.

For example, if you bring your old TV monitor to MediaMarkt the store would be required to take it from you when you purchase a new one.

Alternatively, bigger electronics, or larger loads of items can be disposed of at your local Recyclinghof or Wertstoffhof.

You can also search for your closest registered drop-off location for specific items on this e-scrap return finder

Or, for more information about trading-in or reselling old electronics, check-out this explainer.

Why you shouldn’t throw them away

It’s important to dispose of e-waste properly because of its unique environmental impacts.

“If electronic waste is disposed of incorrectly, valuable raw materials are lost and the heavy metals, flame retardants and plasticizers it contains endanger the environment,” explained DUH’s Federal Managing Director in a published statement.

READ ALSO: EXPLAINED – Why and how to start a zero-waste lifestyle in Germany

In an effort to reduce e-waste, the EU adopted the so-called “right to repair” directive earlier this year, which will require electronics manufacturers to offer reasonably priced repair services and therefore hopefully reduce consumers’ need to buy new electronics.

In the meantime, you can drop off your smaller electronics at the grocery store.

SHOW COMMENTS