SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

READER INSIGHTS

‘Seven complaint emails’: My four-month ordeal renewing a UK passport from Germany

When The Local reader Michelle Jung applied to renew her UK passport from Germany, she had no idea that the process would take months on end. Here's her account of the ordeal - and why she is concerned for other Brits abroad.

A British and German passport.
A British and German passport. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Britta Pedersen

Michelle Jung runs a childcare centre and lives in the Schwarzwald (Black Forest) area. She moved to Germany from the UK in the mid-1990s.

There are many ways to increase your stress levels. Some all-time favourites of mine are trying to rebook a flight and telephone banking. But of all the memorable, blood-surging and heart muscle-tightening moments that I have experienced, nothing can top the interlude I have had with the passport office in the UK these last months. For those Brits living across in Germany who would also like to increase their stress levels, please read on and hear my story.

Earlier on this year I discovered that my British passport needed to be renewed at the latest in September. Being the efficient and foreseeing person that I am (well partly) I decided to get on with the procedure quickly, leaving plenty of time for unexpected difficulties. As an expat living in Germany and extremely far away from the British Embassy, the only possible way to go about my passport renewal was to do it online. I read up beforehand and collected all the necessary documents to send away. It all seemed relatively straightforward and I was confident that I would soon be holding my newly issued passport in my hand (small break for a chuckle).

READ ALSO: How foreigners can get fast track citizenship in Germany 

‘Queezy feeling’

I hit my first obstacle at the local passport studio where a kind but over-challenged – and probably not the most cosmopolitan photographer in the world – told me that he doesn’t offer digital codes for international passports. He said he’d heard of something of the kind as if he were saying, “Oh yeah, I’ve heard of that rare breed of Mongolian wild horses.” Not to be discouraged, I phoned around various photo studios in the Black Forest. I was slightly perturbed to find that no photo studio in this region offers this service. 

Passport control lines at Hamburg airport.

Passport control lines at Hamburg airport. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Christian Charisius

Never one for being put off lightly I went back to the UK passport website and discovered that I could install an app on my phone to take my own passport photo. The App is free and seemed user friendly. It’s not possible to use on your own, but hey, why have we got husbands? My husband and I went through all the steps thoroughly and managed to take what I thought was a jolly good passport photo. The photo cost five pounds to submit but at least I now had everything needed for my passport renewal.

According to the passport website, all documents needed to be sent to Durham, England (which I assumed was a kind of passport office headquarters in the UK). I had a queasy feeling sending my original British passport off in the post but apart from it getting lost what could go wrong? Just to be on the safe side I sent everything as registered mail. As I have dual citizenship (thank God) I also needed to send a copy of my German passport. The £150 fee was transferred with online banking. After everything was submitted I smugly rubbed my hands with glee and ticked off point “renew passport” on my to-do list. Shortly after, I received a mail from the passport office to confirm that they had got my application. That was May 29th. 

Two weeks later I received a kind and quirky mail from the passport office informing me that my passport photo didn’t meet the requirements and a new one was needed. I wasn’t too unsettled and since I didn’t technically take the photo and could put all the blame on my husband I was optimistic enough to think I could send another photo via the app. Together we thoroughly examined the instructions in the app and after what seemed like a two-hour photo session we came up with an extremely professional-looking passport photo. The photo was submitted on the same day – with another five pound payment – and shortly after we received a  confirmation from the passport office.

Two weeks later we received the same friendly and slightly quirky mail informing us that the photo didn’t meet up to required standards. In the meantime, I received a separate mail from the passport office informing me that I needed to send a copy of my German passport to the Liverpool passport office. Now I was at a loss. How on earth do I get an accepted photo sent across? And why do I suddenly need to send a document which has been sent to Durham to Liverpool?

Communication breakdown 

Since all previous mail from the passport office was written anonymously and in an aggravatingly machine-like manner, I decided to try my luck with the customer service hotline to sort out these problems. If you have money to waste and bags of time during the day you might want to try this hotline yourself. It’s a simple procedure really: you dial a number, go through a series of standard questions (don’t forget to say that you don’t want the call in Welsh), wait half an hour listening to Beethoven’s 6th Symphony, get through to someone who, after hearing your story tells you he can’t help and will put you through to someone else, wait a further half hour with classical music in the background before getting someone new at the other end.

At this point of the procedure the call can go in three different directions (I’ve experienced all three of them). Firstly, the person can say they can’t find your application in the system and you burst dramatically into tears. Secondly, the person can listen patiently to your story and tell you how terribly awful you have been treated and encourage you to write a cover letter (despite the passport office sending mails informing all recipients NOT to send a cover letter). The third response can be for a person to note down everything you’ve said and promise to pass on the information to the relevant department with an assurance that your case is now a priority and someone from the passport office will be in touch. Now it gets interesting. I was asked to give a phone number so that someone could speak directly with me. The only snag was that you could only give a UK number. Yes, you have heard right. A government body dealing with passports for people living overseas will only speak to them on the phone in the UK. Now I had to get my mum into this mess. She had just as much success as I had.

At the end of July I sent print photos taken at a passport studio with a cover letter to the Liverpool office. (Incidentally, during one of my many expensive phone calls I found out by chance that the Liverpool passport office was now responsible for my case). I got a confirmation that the photos had arrived but unfortunately my status in the application procedure never changed and I was still stuck in “waiting for approval”. Whilst out visiting my family at the beginning of August I decided to go to a photo studio and send a digital code to the passport office since I had received no approval from the print photos. The code was submitted but my status still didn’t change!

I sent seven emails of complaint. I’d like to think that I am a patient, friendly and articulate citizen who deals with all correspondence in a courteous and professional manner. But it became almost humorous when, after explaining in detail all the mishaps per mail, I then received the reply: “We are happy to inform you that your application was submitted on 29th May and is waiting approval.”

In the week beginning September 19th (so four months after my application was submitted) I finally received my new passport. After opening up my passport I couldn’t believe my eyes! The first photo which I took with the passport app and was officially rejected from the passport office was used for the printing of the passport. I don’t know whether to cry or laugh.

Michelle Jung with her British passport.

Michelle Jung with her new British passport. Photo courtesy of Michelle Jung

I have always been proud of being British and I have never ever contemplated the idea of giving up my British citizenship. But I have had several moments during the last months where I have seriously considered giving up. I sincerely hope that other readers have had better experiences than myself. However, I doubt it. After phoning up the British Embassy in a moment of desperation and hearing how they have received hundreds of calls like mine I can only assume that cardiologists all over Germany are being inundated with stressed-out, palpitating Brits needing heart surgery!

The Local got in touch with the UK Home Office to let them know about Michelle Jung’s account and ask them about the delay.  A spokesperson from the HM Passport Office said: “In light of the difficulties in providing replacement photographs that were explained to us by Mrs Jung, her previously submitted photograph was reconsidered.

“This photograph was accepted as meeting the required standard on 29th July and, following the completion of our checks, Mrs Jung’s passport was issued on 8th September.”

Member comments

  1. Sounds awful. Digital passport photos sounds nice. We still take physical photos and bring them in. Lucky for us, Americans here on behalf of NATO, there are passport offices on base that take care of everything for you and brand new passports come back within 4 weeks. It sounds daunting and I’m curious if an appointment and a day trip to the nearest UK embassy/consulate would have made things a lot easier for the author. I might have even bought a cheap roundtrip air ticket and gone back to the UK to renew my passport. 4 months is a crazy long time.

  2. I am so sorry for her terrible ordeal. As an American, I have only the highest of praise for the Frankfurt Consulate office. I lost my passport a couple of years ago and they were very helpful. Everything was explained, my documents gathered and sent off. Within 4 weeks I had my new passport. Thanks to all the wonderful people at the Frankfurt US Consulate.

  3. This feels like an intentional exaggeration for entertainment purposes 😉

    Photo ‘digital codes’ are country specific – you can only get them in the UK for British passports, in Ireland for Irish passports, etc. Digital codes scheme requires photographers to register with the respective countries’ government and it is unrealistic to expect any photographer outside Britain to participate in it (and I’m not even sure if it is allowed by own xenophobic government).

    What you can get instead in every photo studio (and nearly every photo kiosk) are digital passport photos sent to you by e-mail – which then you can directly upload to Passport Office’s website. That’s what I did and got my passport in less than a month (funny enough, I also live in Schwarzwald).

  4. Firstly, sorry to hear this was such an ordeal.

    Echoing Futurix’s post, I paid a photographer a small fee (20 Euro I think) to make sure I had a digital copy of a biometrics-compliant photo that I then uploaded without a code. After that my application was all fine and took less than a month. I think a lot of this is about when you apply. I heard Spring/Summer applications were subject to long delays.

  5. I have had a similar ordeal applying for my daughter’s first British passport post Brexit (although the application was sent in well before Brexit), I had to prove so much more including my father having to contact the Ministry of Defence to prove that he was serving in Singapore at the time of my birth. (That also took ages and a lot of follow up on my father’s part). I was waking up in the night worrying. I was also not receiving the emails to my .de email address, although I did not know this so I missed a deadline by which the passport office would abort the application. So I lost the money, gave myself a long break before applying again. This time it went smoothly but it took a month after posting before acknowledgement of receipt and then 4 months before it came in the post!! I think the fees are exorbitant and downright insulting considering we are British citizens. My daughter’s German passport and my ID card did not cost nearly as much.
    On the positive side, our local photographers studio here in Berlin did know about digital photos!

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

READER INSIGHTS

‘No-one will offer me a job’: How having a foreign name affects life in Germany

From finding a flat and applying for jobs to dating, does having a foreign name make life harder in Germany? We spoke to our readers to find out.

'No-one will offer me a job': How having a foreign name affects life in Germany

Life in Germany can be challenging sometimes. Whether it’s the stress of finding an apartment, trying to progress in your chosen career or navigating the world of online dating, foreigners face many of the same difficulties Germans do – but they may also face more disadvantages.

Recently, a now-deleted post on social media outlet Reddit claimed to have “cracked the code” for finding a job in Germany. The author of the post had gone from receiving a response on around 1 in 40 applications to receiving a response to around 1 in 4 – all after changing their name to a German-sounding one. 

As dramatic as this may sound, it is far from the only story of name-based discrimination in Germany.

Foreigners regularly complain of being passed over for apartments, regardless of their financial status, because their status as an “outsider” is obvious from their name. From dating apps to the doctors’ surgery, can a foreign name sometimes act as an albatross around your neck, making it harder to succeed in the Bundesrepublik?

When The Local surveyed readers on the issue, the answer appeared to be “yes”. Around three quarters (76 percent) of respondents said that their name had affected their life in Germany, with 12 percent saying it hadn’t and a further 12 percent saying they didn’t know.

Of those affected, around 90 percent said it had either impacted their lives moderately or to an extreme degree, with 30 percent saying that it had had a profound impact on their lives.

Finding an apartment and looking for a job emerged as the areas where people felt most discriminated against, with 64 and 60 percent citing these issues respectively. Career progression (44 percent), online dating (40 percent) and applying for loans (20 percent) came next, with eight percent also mentioning discrimination in a medical setting, such as a clinic or GP’s office.

READ ALSO: What Germans really think about the country’s racism problem

Adithya Srinivasan, a 29-year-old software developer living in Berlin, charted his experience of house-hunting in a blog on his website. Having applied for 36 apartments and been ghosted on each of his applications, he decided to use the name of his then-partner instead, who had a German-sounding name.

Immediately, he started getting responses, either to say that the apartment had been taken or to invite the couple to viewings.

Ultimately, after just 11 applications using the new name, the pair were offered a place to live. 

‘Implied’ discrimination

Though a case like Adithya’s may feel clear-cut, the problem faced by many foreigners who experience this kind of discrimination is that it is often more implied than explicit.

This can lead foreigners to wonder if they’re building things up in their heads, or whether they really are being treated differently. 

Berlin resident Tarik, 30, said he felt like he received more rejections on dating apps due his foreign-sounding name – but that he had no way to prove it.

Shah, 34, said he had received abuse on dating apps, struggled to find an apartment and had also had difficulties in his job search.

“People just don’t invite you unless they have an alternative,” he said.

A user scrolls on popular dating app Tinder. Foreigners have complained of the difficulty of dating in Germany with a non-German name. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Sina Schuldt

A similar problem was faced by, Mr. Heriberto, a 53-year-old US citizen of Hispanic descent who has been struggling to find a job in Germany.

“It doesn’t matter that I have two university degrees and one is a Bachelor of Science; I have sent over 300 CVs in the course of one year and no-one will offer me a job,” he said, adding: “I firmly believe it is because of my foreign-sounding name.”

READ ALSO: Do internationals face discrimination in the German workplace?

The Baden-Württemberg resident also said he faced xenophobia on the street on a regular basis. 

“I have been told several times to get out of Germany, even though I am married to a German and have three children,” he said. “It is utterly disgusting how poorly I have been treated here.”

Summing up the issue, one respondent who also lives in Baden-Württemberg said that xenophobia in Germany could be difficult to prove but was clearly felt by those who experienced it. 

“Germany has a long way to go compared to the English-speaking West when it comes to ingrained, systemic xenophobia,” they said. “This is often implied rather than clearly demonstrated, making it difficult to prove, but clearly experienced and felt by anyone who is ‘different’.”

‘People won’t go on a date with you’

Just like Adithya in his house search, many foreigners are tempted to test the waters with a real – or imagined – German name to see if they receive a better response.

One respondent who preferred to remain anonymous said that they had done this while both flat hunting and looking for a job.

“Recruiters have rejected my CV but called me for an interview when I changed my name to an imaginary German name on the exact same CV,” they revealed. “Landlords have refused my application outright, but accepted when a German friend applied.” 

When job offers had been given, they added, they had sometimes have to contend with salary offers that were up to €30,000 lower than anticipated. 

A sign outside Stuttgart Jobcenter.

A sign outside Stuttgart Jobcenter. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Christoph Schmidt

“The hiring team implied that I was not German enough despite being highly qualified and with more than 12 years of experience,” they said.

READ ALSO: Foreigners in Germany fearful over rise of far right

This feeling of being held back and underestimated was echoed by 39-year-old Vipul, a Munich resident who has lived in Germany for more than 16 years. 

“I can say with complete authority that one’s name is everything in Germany,” he explained. “You can’t really progress in your career beyond a certain point, no matter your credentials, and no matter how brilliant you might be.”

Beyond the struggle to build a career, Vipul said he had experienced everyday racism in places that are meant to be caring environments, like doctors’ surgeries and hospitals, as well as in numerous other contexts.

“In this so-called super-diverse country, people won’t even go out on a date with you if you are a foreign man with a ‘strange’ name,” he said. “And of course, the worst kind of xenophobia, or discrimination occurs when you want to find a place to live. It’s one’s worst nightmare!”

Coming from the ‘right’ country

US-citizen Helen, who lives in Bonn, encapsulated the feeling of many readers: “In every aspect of life, having a foreign name is a disadvantage in Germany.”

However, some pointed out that there were also degrees to the discrimination foreigners faced – particularly when it comes to your country of origin.

“I have been treated with scepticism on numerous occasions given that I have a visibly non-German name,” said one reader who lives in North Rhine-Westphalia. “I do come from what Germans consider to be one of the ‘right countries’ but this has not necessarily made things easier.”

Nevertheless, this sense of the ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ countries – of the cultural insiders and outsiders – appears to cut to the heart of why, seemingly, a name is everything in Germany.

People enter the immigration office

For foreigners who move to Germany and settle in Berlin, a visit to the Berliner Landesamt für Einwanderung (LEA) is ultimately unavoidable. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Britta Pedersen

That was the view of 36-year-old Andrés, who said he had noticed a distinct difference between the treatment of Europeans and non-Europeans in Germany, and particularly those from the Global South.

“Sadly, it seems to depend not on the name itself sounding foreign, but to where specifically the name might be from,” he explained. “My Spanish name has made no difference at all, but I’ve seen people with Middle Eastern names have a different experience.”

READ ALSO: The biggest culture shocks for foreigners in Germany

By a stroke of luck, Freiburg resident Sonny was given his nickname as a youngster, having grown up in a country where only Islamic or native names are allowed in official documents.

As a non-Muslim, he identified more with the nickname than his official name – which has proved to be an advantage in Germany. 

“Every time I use the nickname, it is much easier to get the initial talk going for people to get to now me as a person first and then I don’t care if they get a surprise seeing my name in official documents,” he explained.

“If I use my official name to begin with, I don’t even receive a response!”

For Sonny, the answer to the dilemma is clear: “My ‘life priority’ is to get a new identity after citizenship,” he said. 

READ ALSO: High costs, long queues and discrimination – What it’s like to rent in Germany

SHOW COMMENTS