SHARE
COPY LINK

POLITICS

Macron government survives three no-confidence votes

Three votes of no-confidence in Emmanuel Macron's government - including one which saw far-right leader Marine Le Pen worked together with the leftist alliance - were defeated in parliament on Monday night.

Macron government survives three no-confidence votes
French far-right party Rassemblement National (RN) parliamentary group leader Marine Le Pen speaks in parliament. Photo by JULIEN DE ROSA / AFP

Both Le Pen’s Rassemblement National (RN) and the Nupes alliance of leftist parties had proposed motions of no confidence in the government, in protest over its handling of the budget debates.

With neither party willing to support each other, there seemed no chance of either bill passing, but on Monday afternoon Le Pen announced that her party would support the Nupes bill. However their combined vote was 239 MPs – short of the 289 required to bring down the government.

Two other motions of no confidence – another on the budget proposed by RN alone and one on the social security bill proposed by Nupes – were also defeated.

The government therefore lives to fight another day and the 2023 budget is officially adopted.

The centre-right party Les Républicains declined to support any of the votes, but their leader Olivier Marleix did not rule it out in future, telling Radio J: “If one day we have to vote on a motion of no-confidence, it will be the one we choose to file. And we do not rule out doing so.”

If Nupes, Rassemblement National and Les Républicains all joined together in voting for a no-confidence bill, they would likely have enough votes for it to pass.

Macron has already said that if a no-confidence vote passes, he will dissolve parliament and call new parliamentary elections.

A no-confidence vote does not directly threaten Macron’s position as president, but would leave him effectively unable to govern until new elections were called. At present his LREM group is the largest group in the parliament, but lacks an overall majority.

Because of this lack of majority Borne was unable to get the 2023 budget passed, and so used a constitutional tool known as Article 49.3 in order to force it through the blocked parliament. The motions of no confidence were called in response to the use of this power.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

POLITICS

French PM says new government names will be revealed ‘before Sunday’

France's long-running political deadlock finally reached a conclusion on Thursday night as newly-appointed prime minister Michel Barnier travelled to the Presidential palace to present his new government.

French PM says new government names will be revealed 'before Sunday'

Prime Minister Michel Barnier’s office said on Thursday that he would “go to the Elysée to propose to the president a government that is ready to serve France”.

After a meeting earlier on Thursday afternoon with the heads of political parties, Barner then travelled to the Elysée Palace on Thursday evening to meet president Emmanuel Macron.

Their meeting lasted for just under an hour and at the end journalists saw Macron showing Barnier out saying Merci beaucoup, à demain (thanks very much, see you tomorrow).

After the meeting, Barnier’s office said he had had a “constructive exchange” with the president and that the full list of names of the new ministers will be made public “before Sunday, after the usual checks have been made”.

French media reported that the full list of 38 names, of which 16 will be full minsters, includes seven ministers from Macron’s centrist group, two from fellow centrists MoDem and three from Barnier’s own party, the right-wing Les Républicains.

Listen to John Lichfield discussing the challenges that Barnier faces in the latest episode of the Talking France podcast – download here or listen on the link below

Barnier’s statement said that “after two weeks of intensive consultations with the different political groups” he has found the architecture of his new government, adding that his priorities would be to;

  • Improve the standard of living for the French and the workings of public services, especially schools and healthcare
  • Guarantee security, control immigration and improve integration
  • Encourage businesses and agriculture and build upon the economic attractiveness of France
  • Get public finances under control and reduce debt

France has been in a state of limbo ever since parliamentary elections in July produced a deadlock with no group coming close to winning enough seats for a majority.

A caretaker government remained in place over the summer while president Emmanuel Macron declared an ‘Olympics truce’.

He finally appointed the right-wing former minister and ex-Brexit negotiator Michel Barnier on September 5th.

Barnier has spent the last two weeks in intense negotiations in his attempt to form a government that won’t immediately be brought down through a motion of no-confidence in parliament.

Numerous left-wing politicians are reported to have refused to serve in his government while several high-profile Macronists have also ruled themselves out, including long-serving finance minister Bruno Le Maire who last week announced that he was quitting politics.

The reported make up of the new government does not reflect the election result – in which the leftist Nouveau Front Populaire coalition came first, followed by Macron’s centrists with the far-right Rassemblement National in third – but Barnier’s hope is that enough MPs will support it to avoid an immediate motion de censure (vote of no confidence).

The government’s first task will be to prepare the 2025 budget, which is already a week late. France’s soaring budget deficit and threat of a downgrade from ratings agencies mean that it will be a tricky task with Barnier, who has prepared the ground for tax hikes by warning that the situation is ‘very serious’.

SHOW COMMENTS