SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

CULTURE

Why Spaniards are falling out of love with English-language music

Despite the fact that English-speaking stars like Taylor Swift and Harry Styles regularly sell out Spanish arenas, the reality of what Spaniards are actually listening to paints quite a different picture.

Why Spaniards are falling out of love with English-language music
Spaniards listening to less English language music isn't a unique thing, but part of a broader trend at the global level. (Photo by Angela Weiss / AFP)

New research has revealed that the number of young Spaniards listening to English-language music is in decline, with a surge in popularity for Latin-influenced hits pushing it out the charts.

According to rankings of hit singles, in the last seven years English has began to disappear from the charts in Spain.

In that time, all songs that topped the charts were in Spanish, something that would’ve been very different twenty or thirty years ago. The only exception to that list? Milionària, a June 2019 No.1 single by Spanish superstar Rosalía – in Catalan.

What explains this decline in English-language music?

The Economist investigated changing musical tastes around the world, focusing on both languages and countries.

They analysed the 100 most popular songs in 70 countries according to Spotify, as well as 13,000 hits in 70 different languages while crunching the numbers on other data such as the genre, lyrical language and nationality of the artist, hoping to group types of listeners together.

From this, three main listener groups emerged: a dominant native English-speaking sphere; a smaller but rapidly growing Spanish-speaking ecosystem; and another more, mixed third groups that mostly enjoys local songs in a variety of different languages.

Across all groups (even the English speakers) an undeniable trend emerged: the long-held hegemony of English-language music is in decline.

And this isn’t just in Spain, but globally. In 2020, the most listened to artist in the world was Bad Bunny — a Puerto Rican Latin Trap music star widely credited with helping Spanish language music to go mainstream in recent years. In 2020, the trap star was listened to over 8.3 billion times.

That same year, the increase in Latin music in the United States was a whopping 28 percent, more than double the previous year, according to data from the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA). In 2022, there was another increase of 23 percent compared to 2021.

Not only are English language songs and artists seemingly declining in popularity, but Spanish language music is growing in streaming numbers even among non-native speakers.

Puerto Rican singer Bad Bunny is the world’s most streamed artist. (Photo by VALERIE MACON / AFP)
 

English out?

Within the Spanish-language group of listeners analysed, English-language hits plummeted from 25 percent of songs listened to 14 percent, as Spanish-speaking artists such as the aforementioned Bad Bunny, Maluma, J Balvin, Ozuna, Karol G, Rauw Alejandro and other mainly Latin American performers exploded onto the mainstream scene.

Interestingly, in countries with strong local musical cultures (countries like Japan, France and Brazil, for example) English-language songs decreased even more abruptly, going from 52 percent of successful songs to only 30 percent.

That is to say, Spaniards listening to less English language music isn’t a unique thing, but part of a broader trend at the global level.

READ ALSO: Why does Spain dub every foreign film and TV series?

The growth of streaming services has massively increased the accessibility of Spanish-speaking music to listeners around the world. 

Data from streaming service TIDAL shows that since 2020, the monthly share people streaming Latin content has increased by 9 percent. 

Away from the music industry, Spanish language music has also enjoyed a bit of a cultural boom because of social media influencers: in particular the Kardashian clan, some of which have a friendship with Rosalía and have included clips from her songs in their social media posts, exposing Spanish-language music to millions more people around the world.

In short, Spanish songs (as well as Latin culture) have become cool.

Similarly, the boom in Spanish music, particularly Latin trap, has been helped significantly by effective marketing campaigns and an understanding of digital tools.

By using an established British or American star to collaborate with, Spanish language artists open up their market audience and exposure in a way that most English or Americans artists can’t.

Rauw Alejandro and Rosalía, formerly Latin music’s power couple, perform at Coachella. Photo: Frazer Harrison/Getty Images for Coachella/AFP
 

The Spanish case

“I think that the Spanish market has always has always done its own thing when compared to the rest of Europe or the US, since there have been genres that have not even entered the market on a massive scale, such as hip-hop,” music commentator Noel Turbulencias is quoted as saying by the Huffington Post. 

“It may also be related to the level of English – it used to be at least – in terms of being able to sing the songs or understand what they’re saying”.

The quality of music production has only recently caught up in Spain and Latin America.

“In the past, there were Spanish songs that would have been hits, but they were recorded poorly,” argues Juanma Ortega, CEO of Adio FM.

“There are many groups that did not survive because of the sound, because their message does not reach you. With Phil Collins or Pink Floyd you felt it more, whether you understood the lyrics or not.” 

READ ALSO: How Spain is becoming Hollywood’s European film set again

Spain’s indie rock scene also saw a major change in 2006, when all of a sudden groups such as Sidonie, Anni B Sweet, Love of Lesbian, Fuel Fandango or Deluxe all went from singing in English to Spanish, following hits in Castilian by groups such as Los Piratas or Los Planetas.

“Spanish was the best language to reach their audience with, the one in which they expressed themselves best in and in which their audience would understand them best,” Noel Turbulencias concludes.

However, it is Latin pop – be it trap, reggaeton or electro – which reigns supreme in Spain currently, thanks to a combination of a common shared language and the global popularity of its artists.

Even the biggest Spanish names of the moment – Rosalía, Omar Montes, and Quevedo to name a few – all incorporate Latin sounds into their music. 

Article by Conor Faulkner and Alex Dunham

READ ALSO:

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

OPINION AND ANALYSIS

OPINION: Young black stars mirror migrants’ contribution to Spain

Both Lamine Yamal and Nico Williams are the children of first-generation migrants in Spain; their skin colour and standout performances at Euro 2024 say plenty about the country’s changing demographics and reliance on migration to keep afloat. 

OPINION: Young black stars mirror migrants' contribution to Spain

It’s hard to fathom that the combined age of arguably Spain’s two most decisive players at this year’s Euros is just 37. 

Barça’s Lamine Yamal (16) and Athletic Bilbao’s Nico Williams (21) have given a renewed verticality and freshness to the stale tiki-taka passing style that La Roja stuck to for some 15 years.

They’re also the first black players for La Selección to be considered the national team’s stars. 

Spain hasn’t historically had a multiracial squad, although in the last five years a few black and mixed-race footballers have donned the red jersey: Thiago, Rodrigo, Ansu Fati and Adama Traoré. 

Fati and Traoré, just like Yamal and Williams, are the sons of African migrants who settled in Spain. 

The national team’s current lighting-fast wingers were both born in Spain – Lamine in Llobregat in Catalonia and Nico in Pamplona in Navarre – but their parents had to work hard to make ends meet before their offspring became stars. 

Watching on from the stands during Spain’s 4-1 win over Georgia on Sunday was Williams’ older brother and Athletic team-mate Iñaki, a Ghana international, who looked after him as a child when their father was working in England and their mother was doing multiple jobs in Bilbao.

In Lamine’s case, his mother is from Equatorial Guinea and his father is Moroccan, bringing their son up in the working-class neighbourhood of Rocafonda in the Catalan town of Mataró.

Both players had offers from their parents’ countries to represent their national sides but they chose Spain, their country of birth, mother tongue and upbringing. 

They are Spanish after all, and a representation of how Spain is becoming increasingly multicultural, equally due to global migration trends as to Spanish necessity.

Spain has one of the lowest birth rates in Europe (1.2 children on average) but immigrant families buck that trend, especially African women in Spain, who have on average 3.4 children. 

Currently, one in three children born in Spain have at least one foreign parent, which explains why they’ve been described as a “demographic life jacket” by the Spanish press. 

Eighty percent of them feel Spanish, according to a 2016 study by the Ortega Y Gasset Institute, compared to a measly 6 percent in the US. It’s also more common than ever for children in Spain to grow up with a mix of cultures – 16.9 percent.

Far-right Vox party may prefer that these new Spaniards be “pureblood” Josés and Marías but such wishes are not only racist, they’re delusional. 

READ MORE: The real reasons why Spaniards don’t want to have children

Migrants have effectively solved the threat of Spain’s declining population, even though the issue of severe underpopulation in “Empty Spain” is still present (nonetheless, in rural areas migration is having a positive impact). 

The country is set to gain another five million people by 2039, and foreigners account for almost 100 percent of this population growth.

After all, regardless of origins, new blood is needed to fill jobs and pay the pensions of Spain’s increasingly ageing population (set to be the longest living on the planet by 2040). 

Additionally, data from Spain’s Social Security ministry shows that foreign workers have bolstered a solid post-pandemic recovery by the Spanish labour market.

Almost one third of all jobs created in Spain since the end of Covid-19 pandemic have been filled by foreign workers.

Yamal and Williams are a representation of the changing face of Spain – younger, more multiracial and with it, hopefully, more tolerant. 

A 2022 by Spanish youth association FAD found that 75 percent of young Spaniards don’t have racist or xenophobic opinions, whilst 25 percent do. 

The success of the current poster boys of Spanish football – with more than 50 million fans on TikTok combined – can hopefully help reduce those intolerance levels among the future generations even further.

SHOW COMMENTS