SHARE
COPY LINK

GERMAN CITIZENSHIP

Could Germany strip citizenship rights from foreigners over anti-Semitism?

A bill that would see foreigners with an 'anti-Semitic attitude' lose their rights to German citizenship will be debated in the Bundestag on Friday, along with plans to revoke citizenship from foreigners convicted of anti-Semitic crimes.

Cologne Synagogue during carnival
Police stand on guard at Cologne Synagogue during the opening of carnival. German politicians are pushing for stronger punishments for foreigners found to be anti-Semitic. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Thomas Banneyer

The proposed changes to citizenship and immigration law were drafted by the opposition CDU party, who said they wanted “to provide better protection against the further consolidation and spread of anti-Semitism ‘immigrated’ from abroad”.

The draft law sets out a number of amendments that would make a foreigner’s right to citizenship conditional on their acceptance of the state of Israel and the absence of anti-Semitic views or offences.

In concrete terms, foreigners who want to naturalise as Germans would have to explicitly acknowledge Israel’s right to exist and would be barred from citizenship if they had “pursued endeavours directed against the state of Israel”. 

If there are “factual, unsubstantiated indications of an anti-Semitic attitude on the part of the applicant”, foreigners would also be blocked from ever obtaining a German passport.

READ ALSO: German police raid scores of properties in fight against anti-Semitism

In addition, the conservatives are pushing to include a new clause in the nationality law that would allow citizens with multiple nationalities to be stripped of their German passport.

“Persons with at least one other nationality lose their German citizenship if they are convicted of an anti-Semitic offence and sentenced to at least one year in prison,” the bill states.

This would impact not just newly naturalised Germans, but also those born in Germany to foreign parents who have kept their parents’ citizenship. 

Refugees, meanwhile, would forfeit their right to humanitarian protection if they were convicted of an anti-Semitic offence carrying a prison sentence of six months or more.

Friday will see the bill put to its first reading – the first stage of the parliamentary process in which no votes take place. On its third reading, it would need the support of government parties like the Social Democrats (SPD), Greens and Free Democrats (FDP) – or opposition parties like the far-right AfD – in order to pass into law.

A coalition of just a few of these parties backing up the CDU would likely give it the votes it needs, for example the CDU and SPD or the CDU, FDP and AfD.

However, it is unclear if other parties support the proposals.  

‘We’ve imported hatred of Jews’

The CDU’s push to toughen up citizenship law comes after weeks of heated debate following the outbreak of the Israel-Hamas war.

On October 7th, a shock terror attack by Hamas saw at least 1,200 citizens of Israel murdered on Israeli soil, with around 200 civilians subsequently taken hostage.

Since then, Israel’s relentless bombardment of the Gaza Strip has reportedly caused more than 10,000 civilian deaths, 40 percent of whom are thought to be children.

PODCAST: Why is Germany’s landmark dual citizenship law on hold?

Pro-Palestine demonstrations in regions with a high population of foreigners have sparked discussions over whether the country’s migrant population – including many second- and third-generation Turkish migrants and Syrian refugees – are truly aligned with German values.

People march in solidarity with Palestine in Wuppertal

People march in solidarity with Palestine in Wuppertal, North Rhine-Westphalia. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Christoph Reichwein

“We’ve imported hatred of Jews,” said CDU fraction head Dirk Stettner in a recent interview with Tagesspiegel.

In its latest draft law aimed at toughening up citizenship and asylum laws, the party states that those campaigning in favour of Palestine are “obviously immigrants from the countries of North Africa and the Near and Middle East, where anti-Semitism and hostility towards Israel have a particular breeding ground, as well as their descendants”. 

For this reason, the party adds, “the instruments of residence, asylum and citizenship law must be used more consistently than before” in the fight against anti-Semitism.

Delays to citizenship reform

Amid growing fears and suspicions in the wake of October 7th, a flagship reform aimed at liberalising Germany’s citizenship laws was quietly removed from the parliamentary agenda.

The coalition of SPD, Greens and FDP had aimed to bring a first reading of the bill – which among other things will permit dual nationality for non-EU citizens – to the Bundestag on November 9th. 

READ ALSO: INTERVIEW – ‘We are determined to pass German citizenship reforms despite delays’

According to SPD MP Hakan Demir, however, the FDP demanded that the reforms be delayed until new provisions to fight anti-Semitism could be included in the legislation.

“The question mark that they have right now is if the new citizenship act is good enough to prevent anyone who is anti-Semitic from getting German citizenship,” Demir told The Local.

This could include asking would-be Germans to explicitly acknowledge Israel’s right to exist as part of the naturalisation process.

According to FDP sources, the bill could still go to the Bundestag in the week of November 27th, assuming amendments are made by then.

The Local has contacted the CDU, FDP and Interior Ministry for comment but at the time of publication had not received a response. 

Member comments

  1. I truly respect the German government on its position and its moral clarity on this one. Other countries should follow suit.

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

POLITICS

Citizenship reform: How a German minister you’ve never heard of is changing the lives of foreigners

Germany's coalition government is struggling. It's flagging in polls, sports few concrete policy wins, and its foreign policy is hotly debated. A notable exception is Interior Minister Nancy Faeser - a Social Democrat who remains a little discussed figure - despite overseeing legislation that hits at the core of Germany's identity.

Citizenship reform: How a German minister you've never heard of is changing the lives of foreigners

After all, few things are as existential to a country’s identity as deciding who gets to be a national or who gets to settle there and be a part of its community.

As Germany’s Interior Minister since late 2021, Faeser has been responsible for overseeing historic legislation on both. At a time when other European countries are tightening up citizenship and immigration rules – even for skilled, well-integrated immigrants – Faeser’s German Interior Ministry is betting on more openness.

March saw sweeping immigration reforms – designed to make it easier for skilled workers to come to Germany, bring their parents if they wish, and even come before having their foreign qualifications recognised by Germany’s notorious bureaucracy.

Skilled workers also have a faster route to permanent residence in Germany – after just 21 months in some cases.

Late 2024 will also see the introduction of the points-based Chancenkarte – or “opportunity card”. A German first, people with enough points could theoretically come to Germany without a firm job offer and look for work while already here. They might even be able to come if they don’t speak German yet – if they have enough points in other areas. In a country not normally known for its flexibility, Faeser’s Interior Ministry is showing much more of it in a bid to combat the country’s skilled labour shortage.

READ ALSO: The changes to Germany’s immigration rules in March 2024

Landmark citizenship reform

Many Local readers will also be familiar with another landmark piece of legislation from Faeser’s desk – Germany’s long-awaited dual nationality reform. After having seen repeated delays due to disputes between the three governing coalition parties, the Federal President finally signed and certified the new citizenship law in late March – starting a three-month countdown for the country’s bureaucracy to adapt to the new rules.

On June 26th, German citizenship law will allow people to hold multiple nationalities when naturalising and shorten the time someone will have needed to be in Germany before applying for citizenship from eight years to five.

Many people are becoming German

American Rick Hoffmann, Aussie-Italian Joe Del Borrello and Brazilian-Canadian Dini Silviera are looking forward to applying to becoming German following passage of the government’s dual citizenship reform. Photos: Rick Hoffmann, Joe Del Borrello, Dini Silviera

It’s not been without its controversy, with the country’s Christian Democrats (CDU) remaining vocal opponents until the end. CDU MP Alexander Throm described it as a “citizenship devaluation law” that has “the most wide-reaching negative consequences for our country” during the Bundestag session that saw the law’s final passage.

During that same debate, SPD MP Dirk Wiese pointed out a historical symmetry – namely that Faeser, a Social Democrat from Hesse, was responsible for passing dual nationality legislation that a CDU Premier of Hesse has originally torpedoed 25 years ago.

READ ALSO:

Throm was right about one thing. The results of Faeser’s legislation are likely to have long-lasting, far-reaching effects. Both the new law’s supporters and detractors can at least agree on its importance.

It may well end up being one of the longest-lasting legacies of the traffic light government. Even if the CDU take the Chancellery again in 2025 – as current polls would suggest – no other possible coalition partner is likely to agree to repeal the law. Dual nationality in Germany – and with it the acceptance of multifaceted identity – is likely here to stay, even if a future CDU-led government manages to tighten up immigration or asylum law in the future.

Nancy Faeser Boris Rhein

SPD candidate and Interior Minister Nancy Faeser and CDU candidate Boris Rhein in Wiesbaden, Hesse during the election campaign. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Boris Roessler

Faeser’s non-flashy style

Despite the weighty nature of the legislation she’s shepherded through her ministry and the Bundestag, Faeser isn’t known for grand pronouncements. She’s largely left it to others to make the public case for the dual nationality law’s importance, like parliamentary rapporteurs Hakan Demir (SPD), Filiz Polat (Green), and Stephan Thomae (FDP). She’s comfortable giving breakfast show interviews but rarely hits the evening talk show circuit.

A legislative workhorse, Faeser just seems to move on to her next task without a lot of fanfare for the one she just completed. The reason is likely equally unglamorous – she just has a lot to get done. Today immigration and citizenship reform, tomorrow proposals to tighten gun controls in Germany or issue visa bans for Russian athletes. She also found time to be her party’s top candidate in last autumn’s state election in her home state of Hesse.

Having never had a federal office before becoming Interior Minister, Faeser came from Hessian state politics, where she served as a member of the state parliament from 2003 to 2021, eventually becoming the Hessian SPD state party leader in 2019. At the time she became a minister in 2021, few Germans outside of Hesse had heard of her – never mind internationals.

Nancy Faeser smiles in November 2015 at the SPD state party conference in Kassel (Hesse).

Nancy Faeser smiles in November 2015 at the SPD state party conference in Kassel (Hesse). Photo: picture alliance / dpa | Uwe Zucchi

Media outlets both inside and outside of Germany keep their main focuses on politicians like Chancellor Olaf Scholz, Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock, Vice-Chancellor Robert Habeck or Finance Minister Christian Lindner. With the controversy over Berlin’s strategy in Russia’s war against Ukraine, this is perhaps understandable.

But such a focus might sometimes miss another fundamental shift currently underway in Germany – as the country changes its approach to who gets to be a member of its national community. Nancy Faeser may well be one of the few members of the current German government to have a legacy that lasts well beyond her time in office.

Agree with her policies or not, that deserves more German and international reflection.

SHOW COMMENTS