SHARE
COPY LINK

SCHOOLS

French town tests controversial school uniforms

Hundreds of pupils in southern France headed to school in uniforms for the first time on Monday as part of a national experiment to determine whether to make them compulsory.

French town tests controversial school uniforms
Pupils in uniform listen to their teacher in their classroom, on February 26, 2024. (Photo by Pascal GUYOT / AFP)

Uniforms have never been required in state schools in mainland France.

But centrist President Emmanuel Macron last month announced a uniform trial at around 100 schools, with a view to making them mandatory nationwide in 2026 if it is successful.

READ MORE: Explained: Why is school uniform controversial in France?

Towns run by the right wing make up the majority that signed up for the test, though some have met strong resistance from teachers, students and parents.

Critics say the money would be better spent in other areas of public education to improve learning.

Around 700 students at four schools in the southern town of Beziers appeared to be the first to try it out in mainland France on Monday, after a school gave identical outfits a go in the overseas territory of La Reunion last month.

In the schoolyard of one primary school, seven-year-old Alexia said she hoped for fewer comments from classmates about her appearance while wearing her new dark blue uniform.

“Sometimes they’d say, ‘you’re ugly, we’re not dressed the same’. It was a bit hurtful,” she said.

Now “at least we’ll have the same skirt, the same top, the same jacket.”

Pupils in Beziers, a town with a far-right mayor and a high unemployment rate, had been invited to come with their parents to pick up their outfit during half term.

The city and national governments are sharing the €200 cost of each uniform, made up of a blazer with the school’s logo, two polo shirts and one pair of trousers, as well as a pair of shorts or a skirt depending on gender.

Mayor Robert Menard said the move would help fight bullying.

“When you’re rich or poor, you don’t dress exactly the same way,” he said. Now “it will be less visible.”

But the SE-UNSA teachers’ union slammed the measure as a “superficial response to a fundamental problem”, adding it would “in no way help resolve the troubles and failures of students”.

‘Peaceful climate’

Education Minister Nicole Belloubet said that so far 92 schools had volunteered to try out a uniform, including towns outside Beziers that had been “more discreet” about it.

“What we would like to see is if, yes or no, wearing a uniform can create tranquillity in classrooms,” said the minister.

“We know you learn better in a peaceful environment.”

Schools have until June to sign up to the initiative.

Those who have rejected it include a middle school in the southern city of Marseille.

The wider Bouches-du-Rhone region — whose head hails from the right-wing Republicans party — had approved the trial, but 66 percent of pupils at the Marseille school voted against it, according to a letter to parents seen by AFP.

In the western village of Plouisy, parents last month staged a protest when they heard the mayor, from Macron’s Renaissance party, had signed up for the test. The idea was dropped.

First lady Brigitte Macron, a former drama teacher, has backed the introduction of school uniforms.

Far-right former presidential candidate Marine Le Pen has also supported a compulsory dress code.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

SCHOOLS

‘Macron’s mean’: French PM gets rough ride at holiday school

France's Prime Minister Gabriel Attal on Monday endured a sometimes abrupt reception at a boarding school taking on children during the Easter holidays as part of an experiment to stem youth violence.

'Macron's mean': French PM gets rough ride at holiday school

The uncomfortable episode at the school also comes with Attal and his government under pressure to make their mark as the anti-immigration far-right National Rally party leaps ahead in polls for the June 9 European Parliament elections.

Such holiday schools are part of a plan aimed at keeping teens off the streets during France’s long school holidays after the country was shaken by a series of attacks on schoolchildren by their peers.

“There’s a violence problem among young people. Tackling the issue is one of my government’s biggest priorities,” Attal told a group of teenagers in uniform tracksuits as he visited the school in the southern city of Nice.

Attal, appointed by Macron in January as France’s youngest ever prime minister, was seen as a telegenic asset in the battle against the far-right.

But his own popularity ratings have been tanking in the recent weeks with the latest poll by Ipsos finding 34 percent approving his work in April, down four percent on March.

When he asked the group who was happy to be there for the Easter holidays, which started on April 20 in the Nice region, most replied in the negative.

“My mother forced me,” said one male student.

“My parents didn’t convince me to go, they forced me, that’s all. I have nothing to say. It was that or home,” said Rayan, 14.

“In any case, you are going to learn lots of things, you are going to do lots of activities,” insisted Attal, adding he was “sure that in the end, you will be happy to be there.”

Another boy seemed not to know who Attal was.

“Are you the mayor or the prime minister?” asked Saif, 13. “Me, I am the prime minister and the mayor, he is there,” said Attal frostily, gesturing to Nice mayor Christian Estrosi.

A young boy asked the former education minister what his job was and if he was rich, then what he thought of the president.

“Macron’s mean,” the boy said looking at his feet, in comments caught on camera and broadcast on the BFMTV television channel.

“What’s that? Why do you say that?” Attal replied as burly Justice Minister Eric Dupond-Moretti moved towards the boy.

“Anyway here you’re going to learn lots,” Attal added.

He also reprimanded another boy for referring to the president simply as “Macron”. “We say Monsieur Macron as with all adults,” he said.

SHOW COMMENTS