SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

TRAVEL NEWS

‘Improve punctuality’: How Germany plans to fix its crisis-hit trains

Transport Minister Volker Wissing is piling pressure on rail operator Deutsche Bahn to improve its services amid dismal punctuality rates. Here's a look at his latest restructuring plan.

An ICE train travels over a railway bridge at a bridge construction site at the Veddel S-Bahn station in Hamburg.
An ICE train travels over a railway bridge at a bridge construction site at the Veddel S-Bahn station in Hamburg. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Christian Charisius

Rail passengers in Germany have seen punctuality rates plummet in recent years. In June it was reported that only around half of long-distance trains arrived at their destination on time.

Operator Deutsche Bahn (DB) has pledged to improve the railway network by investing €16.4 billion in an infrastructure programme over the next six years. 

But this week, Transport Minister Volker Wissing brought several demands to the table aimed at making German train travel more efficient.

Now that the track refurbishment is underway, Wissing said: “Deutsche Bahn must deliver now,” adding that he wants to “see an improvement by 2027”.

Wissing said the goal is for Deutsche Bahn to be “optimally positioned” and become a “reliable mode of transport”.

Here’s a look at the main points of the plan:

  • Improve punctuality, bringing it up to a top level comparable to international standards. Wissing also said DB has to be punctual even when there are extreme weather conditions
  • Improve the capacity utilisation of long-distance trains
  • Review management and cut administration
  • Review investments outside of infrastructure modernisation
  • Improve the efficiency of the rail network operator ‘InfraGo’
  • Driving forward digitalisation
  • Risk management in climate change

READ ALSO: How travelling on German trains has become a nightmare for foreigners

Job cuts and no cancellation of train routes

As well as the focus on punctuality, Wissing is calling for better capacity usage of long-distance trains and fewer management staff.

According to the FDP minister, the operator currently has “too much administration”. Wissing said there should be fewer bosses in management and more staff in operations.

DB already announced at the end of July that it plans to cut around 30,000 jobs within five years – mainly in administration.

Transport Minister Volker Wissing visits a rail construction site in Hesse.

Transport Minister Volker Wissing visits a rail construction site in Hesse. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Andreas Arnold

Wissing also cited cost efficiency in the procurement of materials and on construction sites as one of the most important goals. He added that all areas, including long-distance transport and DB Cargo, are in deficit and there is a need for improvement.

Saving targets should not, however, lead to unprofitable rail routes being axed. Opposition leader Friedrich Merz, of the CDU, suggested in July that the route network should be thinned out to improve punctuality. But Wissing said this “cannot be the aspiration of a company like ours” and that DB should instead run a tightly synchronised operation on time as part of the restructuring project. 

To achieve this, DB has to modernise its infrastructure – a task that is already ongoing. Among the biggest this year is the refurbishment of the Riedbahn between Frankfurt and Mannheim. It closed for renovation in July and is scheduled to reopen fully on December 14th.

READ ALSO: What are the big travel changes in Germany this autumn?

Wissing said Deutsche Bahn has to become more efficient and reliable. “I am now demanding this in concrete terms,” he said.

Bosses at Deutsche Bahn are now required to submit a renovation concept, while the implementation will be closely monitored every three months. Targets are to be set for each year up to 2027 and reviewed by the Transport Ministry. 

A Deutsche Bahn steering group has been set up within the ministry to closely monitor the reorganisation.

READ ALSO: ‘Learn from the Swiss’ – How Germany can solve its endless rail problems

What’s the reaction?

Transport politician Matthias Gastel from the Greens reacted sceptically to Wissing’s plan, saying that his demands were vague.

Other critics had a similar reaction. Previously, the German government has said its short-term goal is to get 70 percent of trains to run on time and to increase this to 80 percent by 2030, but there was no mention of figures in Wissing’s latest call. 

An op-ed in German newspaper Welt said: “Wissing has a seven-point plan, but on the three A4 pages there is not one concrete figure by which the Transport Minister wants to measure the ‘Bahn’ in future. Instead, there are vague declarations of intent.”

Passenger rights groups see the efforts as positive – but also called for more information. 

“The ministry cares about the railways and wants to get involved,” said Andreas Schröder from the passenger association Pro Bahn.

However, he said the paper is “very general” and that there is no explanation of how goals are to be achieved.

The next step is for DB’s supervisory board to discuss the proposal and submit a response to the Transport Ministry.

According to Wissing, the reorganisation plan should be available “as quickly and as concretely as possible”.

READ ALSO: What to know about Deutsche Bahn’s summer service changes

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

TRAVEL NEWS

Germany begins expanded border checks to limit migrant arrivals

Germany from Monday is expanding border controls to the frontiers with all nine of its neighbours to stop irregular migrants in a move that has sparked protests from other EU members.

Germany begins expanded border checks to limit migrant arrivals

The government announced the sweeping measure following a string of deadly extremist attacks that have stoked public fears and boosted support for the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party.

Interior Minister Nancy Faeser on Sunday said that the step aimed to limit irregular migration and “put a stop to criminals and identify and stop Islamists at an early stage”.

The border controls will be in place for an initial six months and are expected to include temporary structures at land crossings and spot checks by federal police.

Poland and Austria have voiced concern and the European Commission has warned that members of the 27-nation bloc must only impose such steps in exceptional circumstances.

Germany lies at the heart of Europe and borders nine countries that are part of the visa-free Schengen zone, designed to allow the free movement of people and goods.

Border controls with Poland, the Czech Republic, Austria and Switzerland were already in place before the crackdown was announced.

These will now be expanded to Germany’s borders with France, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Belgium and Denmark.

Faeser said the government hoped to minimise the impact on people living and working in border regions, promising “coordination with our neighbouring countries”. She also pointed out that there should be “targeted controls, not blanket controls”.

The interior ministry however noted that travellers should carry identification when crossing the border.

READ ALSO: How Germany’s increased border checks will affect travel from neighbouring countries

‘Islamist attacks’

In recent weeks, a string of extremist attacks have shocked Germany, fuelling rising public anger.

Last month, a man on a knife rampage killed three people and wounded eight more at a festival in the western city of Solingen.

The Syrian suspect, who has alleged links to the Islamic State group, had been intended for deportation but managed to evade authorities.

The enforcement failure set off a bitter debate which marked the run-up to two regional polls in the formerly communist east, where the anti-immigration AfD scored unprecedented results.

With national elections looming next year, Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s government has been under intense political pressure to toughen its stance on migrants and asylum seekers.

READ ALSO: Debt, migration and the far-right – the big challenges facing Germany this autumn 

Scholz was in Uzbekistan on Sunday to sign a migration deal for workers to come to Germany, while simplifying deportation procedures in the opposite direction so that “those that must go back do go back”, the chancellor said.

Closer to home, the German government has presented plans to speed up deportations to European partners.

Under EU rules, asylum requests are meant to be handled by the country of arrival. The system has placed a huge strain on countries on the European periphery, where leaders have demanded more burden-sharing.

Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis said that Germany tightening its borders means that it would “essentially pass the buck to countries located on the outer borders of Europe”.

Austria’s Interior Minister Gerhard Karner said his country “will not accept people who are rejected from Germany”, while Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk condemned Germany’s move as “unacceptable”.

‘Welcome to the club’

Warsaw has also struggled with migration and accused Moscow of smuggling people from Africa and the Middle East into Europe by sending them through Belarus to the Polish border.

Berlin on Friday said that Tusk and Scholz had discussed the issue and agreed to strengthen EU external borders, “especially in view of the cynical instrumentalisation of migrants by Belarus”.

Hungary’s nationalist Prime Minister Viktor Orban, meanwhile, mocked the German chancellor on social media site X, writing: “Bundeskanzler Scholz, welcome to the club! #StopMigration.”

Germany took in more than a million asylum seekers in 2015-16, many of them Syrians, and has hosted over a million Ukrainians since the start of the Russian invasion in 2022.

The extra burden on municipal authorities and integration services in Germany needed to be “taken into account” when talking about new border controls, Berlin’s interior ministry said.

In the Netherlands, Prime Minister Dick Schoof on Friday unveiled the country’s strictest migration policy yet, saying it will request an opt-out from EU common policy on asylum next week.

A four-party coalition dominated by far-right firebrand Geert Wilders’s Freedom Party wants to declare an “asylum crisis” to curb the influx of migrants through a tough set of rules including border controls.

By Raphaelle LOGEROT with Celine LE PRIOUX in Berlin

SHOW COMMENTS