SHARE
COPY LINK

BREXIT

ANALYSIS: Many Brits in Spain will soon have to make a life-changing choice

New rules due to Brexit could make it very hard for many Brits in Spain to ever return 'home', writes Graham Keeley in Barcelona. Meaning many will have to start think about the choice they must make.

ANALYSIS: Many Brits in Spain will soon have to make a life-changing choice
Even if my family wanted to swap the beach for rainy London life, could we? Photo: AFP

If you are a foreigner living in Spain, it is the question that lurks at the back of your mind: Should I stay or should I go?

Go on, admit it. However much you enjoy the pleasures of life here – and they are considerable – there is a part of all of us which wonders if this is it, forever? Might we, one day, decide to head home?

Being closer to elderly relatives or other family members might be the game changer. Or, perhaps given the post-Covid-19 economic outlook in Spain, which looks bleak, it might be easier to find work in one's own countries. Maybe if children head to university in another country, this might be a good reason to leave España.

Well, now it seems that if you are British at least, Brexit might force your hand.

The Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (Withdrawal) Act 2020, to give it its full name, may make things much harder for British nationals to go home if they have a foreign partner and family.

According to Fiona Godfrey, of the campaign group British in Europe, from 29 March 2022, the law will change and that is when things get tricky.

“After that if you want to come back with your non-British partner, you’ll need to earn £18,600 a year, a lot more if you have non-British kids,” Godfrey told the Guardian newspaper this week.

“And if your partner wants to move and be able to work in their own right immediately, they’ll have to meet the new points system.”

Godfrey said up to 40 per cent of Britons likely to want to return believe they would not fulfil this income requirement, and most of their partners did not do jobs on the Home Office list of approved professions. Associated costs like NHS surcharges or fees could run into thousands of pounds.

It means that British people living in Spain and other parts of Europe have until March 2022 to make what potentially will be a life-changing choice.

It is difficult to guess but many of the Brits I know here are settled and have no intention of returning to Britain.

But they may have made that decision based on the knowledge that they could go back if they wished and would face little red tape or problems.

Now, this freedom has been taken out of their hands thanks to Brexit, it may also change the way they look at things.

This raises a deeper issue. Where is home, after all? 

It seems some people have really made Spain their home and just regard Britain as somewhere they grew up and left when they were younger.

Others, myself included, have a complex relationship with Britain, which they always refer to as home, as if they were on a rather long holiday in Spain.

I feel like a tourist in Britain now which makes holidays or work trips there all the more fun.

Quite how things might be if I moved back for real with my family is a subject I have turned over in my mind from time to time. Who hasn't?

Could I face those grim months of January and February, the commuting, the daily obsession with the rain/weather or even life in Brexit Britain? A tough one. 


Photo: AFP

 

Then again, there would be plenty of reasons to be cheerful. The pubs, the gags, the fish n'chips, the McEwan's Export (which despite its name is not exported anywhere in the world). Readers, I could go on and on.

It would be a hard sell to a family used to the winter sun, living outside and who blanch at a few drops of rain. Oh, and then there is the beach. They might miss that a bit, I suppose. 

Whatever, I know plenty of Brits who say they do not know whether they will stay in Spain forever but are quite happy for now.

Equally, I know others who have headed home after they decided they had had enough of Spain, better opportunities came up at home or they had to head back to Britain to look after relatives.

I wonder if this legislation will concentrate the minds of Brits, not just those living in Spain but those elsewhere in Europe, about where their futures lie? 

I suspect unless they really have to head back, this will make many less inclined to go back to a country whose decision back in 2016 caused such disruption to the lives of millions.

 

 

 

Graham Keeley is a Spain-based freelance journalist who covered the country for The Times from 2008 to 2019. Follow him on Twitter @grahamkeeley .

 

 

 

READ MORE: 

 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

BREXIT

REVEALED: Thousands of Britons still moving to EU countries despite Brexit

More than 42,000 British citizens moved to EU countries in 2023, with the largest groups recorded in Spain, France and Germany, according to data published recently by the EU statistical office Eurostat.

REVEALED: Thousands of Britons still moving to EU countries despite Brexit

The data refers to the number of first-time residence permits being issued last year.

It’s defined as “any authorisation issued by the authorities of an EU country allowing a third-country national (non-EU citizen) to stay legally on its territory”.

Based on information provided by national authorities to the EU statistical office, 42,029 first-time residence permits were issued to UK citizens in 2023, a slight drop compared to the 45,794 in 2022.

The largest proportion of these permits were issued for employment reasons(13,423), followed by family reunions (11,074), “other reasons” (10,961), and then education (6,571). “Other reasons” include any option not covered by the other three, from retirement to international protection.

Spain and France the most popular

Spain is the country that issued the largest number of new residence permits to UK citizens (10,166), but only 1,266 were because of jobs. Most of the first-time permits (3,768) were issued for ‘other reasons’, followed by family (3,311) and education purposes (1,821).

The recent news that a British football coach was denied a dream move to Real Madrid due to work permit rules showed that Britons can’t move to Spain so easily after Brexit especially for employment reasons.

The coach found out the hard way that getting a work permit to live in Spain is now quite tricky, especially for young Brits, who will need to prove that they’re highly skilled while employers must demonstrate that there are no other suitable candidates.

To give some perspective, although the data is not exactly comparable, Eurostat’s immigration data show that some 23,900 British citizens moved to Spain alone in 2018, and over 33,900 in 2019 – so prior to Brexit.

READ ALSO: The reasons why Brits are moving to Spain post-Brexit

France followed, with 8,114 first residence permits granted to UK nationals (although France’s Interior Ministry released figures earlier this year that revealed a slightly higher number of Brits – 9,261 – had been given residency permits in 2023).

The largest proportion of permits received by Brits in France was for employment reasons (3,649), coming before education (1,798), other reasons (1,666) and family reunions (1,001).

READ ALSO: Thousands of Brits move to France despite post-Brexit hurdles

Germany reported 4,584 first residence permits to UK citizens in 2023, of which 1,765 for work, 1,468 for other reasons, 882 for family reunions and 469 for education.

READ ALSO: The reasons Brits are moving to Germany post-Brexit

The other two most popular countries for British nationals in 2023 were the Netherlands (3,750 first residence permits of which 1,713 for employment) and Portugal (2,565 of which 1,144 for other reasons).

Italy reported 2,177 first residence permits for UK citizens, of which 1,124 for other reasons 621 to join family, 278 for employment and 154 for education.

For Denmark, the total was 1,852, but the majority (1,264) were for work purposes, 280 to join family, 243 for education and 65 other reasons.

Sweden issued 1,632 first residence permits to British nationals, mostly for family reasons (710), followed by employment (474), education (247), and other reasons (201).

Austria reported 529 first residence permits to UK citizens, of which 201 for employment, 191 for family reasons, 70 for education, and 67 for other purposes.

Outside of the EU, but part of the free movement area, Norway registered 1,736 new residence permits to UK nationals, of which 1,033 for employment, 366 to join family, 146 for education, and 201 for other reasons.

In Norway, Britons were the third nationality for first residence permits and in Bulgaria the fourth, although the number of UK citizens moving to Central and Eastern Europe is much lower than in Western Europe.

The Eurostat database does not yet include 2023 data for Switzerland.

Data on first-time residence permits gives a general indication on the number of people who moved to EU countries in a given year, although Eurostat told The Local that “the date of issuance of a permit does not necessarily mean the physical movement of the person on that date, as non-EU citizens might have already temporarily resided on the basis of e.g. short stay visa” or due to irregular stays.

More than 3.7 million first residence permits

In total, in 2023 EU countries reported the granting of more than 3.7 million first residence permits, a 4.7 percent increase compared to 2022, and the highest number ever recorded.

Employment remained the main reason (1.3 million or 33.8%), followed by family (986,000 or 26.4% of the total), other purposes (956,000 or 25.6%) and education (185,900 or 14.3%). The increase compared to 2022 was due to permits issued for education, family reunification and other reasons, while those for employment slightly declined.

The top 10 nationalities receiving these permits were Ukraine, Belarus, India, Morocco, Syria, Türkiye, Russia, China, Brazil and Afghanistan.

Poland issued the largest number of first residence permits in the EU (642,789), followed by Germany (586,144), Spain (548,697), Italy (389,542) and France (335,074).

SHOW COMMENTS