SHARE
COPY LINK

POLITICS

Why’s Spain’s election is a wake-up call for Europe’s right wing

Spain's election, which was won by the right-wing Popular Party but without enough support to govern, marks a rare setback for the growing influence of the political right across Europe, analysts say.

Why's Spain's election is a wake-up call for Europe's right wing
Spanish far-right Vox party leader Santiago Abascal delivers a speech after Spain's general election at the party headquarters in Madrid on July 23, 2023. (Photo by Thomas COEX / AFP)

With barely a year until European elections in June, the PP’s inability to win a governing majority, even with its far-right partner Vox “means the radically conservative, far-right wave has not managed to cross the Pyrenees,” said Steven Forti, a political scientist at Barcelona’s Autonomous University.

“The signal Spain is sending to Europe is that this wave can be stopped”, he told AFP.

READ ALSO: Five key takeaways from Spain’s general election

On paper, the PP won the vote with 136 of the parliament’s 350-seats, followed by the Socialists of outgoing Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez who won 122.

But for Forti, it amounted to little more than a “pyrrhic victory” and even a “political defeat”.

Polls had repeatedly predicted a PP victory, suggesting it would be able to amass an absolute majority with Vox, a troublesome ally due to its extreme positions but nonetheless an essential one if Alberto Núñez Feijóo’s party was to govern.

Such an outcome could have brought the far right into Spain’s government for the first time since the Franco dictatorship ended in 1975.

READ ALSO: Ten things you should know about Spain’s far-right party Vox

Many in Europe thought that Spain was heading down the same path as taken by Sweden and Italy last year, or Finland earlier this year, countries where the right and the far-right have come together to rule.

And in Rome, far-right leader Giorgia Meloni is prime minister, heading Italy’s most far-right coalition since World War II.

Vox’s leader Santiago Abascal is a close ally of Italy’s Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni (L) and Hungary’s Prime Minister Viktor Orban. (Photo by Ludovic MARIN / AFP)
 

But whether the right’s setback in Spain is likely to prompt a rethink in Europe is doubtful says Thierry Chopin, a special adviser at the Institute Jacques Delors.

“It’s not at all certain because each national situation is very different,” he told AFP.

Vox, which emerged out of a split within the PP in 2013, has “a fairly outrageous narrative” and a form of radicalism that is “far from the strategy of trivialisation and respectability” exhibited by similar movements in other European countries, he said.

READ ALSO: What could a Vox government mean for foreigners in Spain?

Throughout its campaign, Vox embarrassed Feijóo with its extreme positions ranging from a refusal to acknowledge gender violence, to its rejection of LGBTQ rights, or opposition to abortion and euthanasia.

Ideological convergence “has not worked” in Spain “as it did in Italy or in northern Europe,” Chopin said.

Sunday’s debacle triggered recriminations between the two parties, with Vox’s secretary general Ignacio Garriga accusing media outlets close to the PP of “demonising and manipulating Vox’s message” in order to win over voters.

But to assess the impact at a European level of Sunday’s right-wing failure in Spain, Forti says it will be necessary to see whether Sánchez and his radical left-wing Sumar allies manage to cling onto power.

If not, Spain will likely head into new elections towards the end of the year, or in early 2024 “just before the European elections” in June, he said.

Ahead of the European elections, the centre-right European People’s Party (EPP), which includes the PP, has been in talks with the right-wing European Conservatives and Reformists Group (ECR), which includes Vox and Meloni’s Brothers of Italy, over a new political alliance within the parliament.

But the outcome of Spain’s election has “really complicated that strategy”, Forti said.

“What has happened in Spain reinforces my opinion that this alliance isn’t a foregone conclusion and that it won’t happen,” he said.

READ ALSO: Spain’s election gridlock – What happens next?

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

POLITICS

Spain’s junior govt partner wants to ban second homes in stressed rental areas

Amid a rental housing crisis in Spain, the government's far-left junior coalition partner wants to ban the purchase of second homes in stressed rental areas and boost the number of social housing units.

Spain's junior govt partner wants to ban second homes in stressed rental areas

Sumar, the far-left junior coalition partner in the Spanish government, has proposed a ban on the speculative buying of second homes in stressed rental areas.

The vice-president and leader of Sumar, Yolanda Díaz, made the announcement as part of her party’s proposals for the 2025 budget. The 36-page document focused primarily on housing and tax reform and aims to tackle social inequality. 

Sumar will now begin negotiating the proposals with its senior government partner, Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez’s Socialist party (PSOE), with headline measures such as banning the purchase of homes for ‘speculation’ in stressed areas and a universal200 per month child-rearing allowance. 

So-called rental ‘stress areas’ were created by Spain’s Housing Law in 2022, a piece of legislation that many consider failed. Despite tenant friendly policies like rent caps, the legislation has done little to stop the spiralling rental costs in Spain since the pandemic.

READ ALSO: Renting a room in Spain costs 90% more than in 2015

Presenting her proposals at an event in Madrid, Díaz, who is also Spain’s Labour Minister, said: “Today we are agreeing on what we want to negotiate with PSOE and on what we have to do. We have a vision for the future of the country. The first pending task is called inequality.”

Second home ban

For many in Spain the most eye-grabbing policy in the budget proposals is the ban on second-home purchases in stressed rental areas.

Sumar proposes to “temporarily ban the purchase of housing in stressed areas for uses other than habitual residence or affordable renting.” 

“In the current emergency situation in our country, the purchase of housing cannot be used for speculative purposes,” reads the text.

It also calls for an increase in the public housing stock, namely “500,000 social rental housing units of between 400-600 [per month] in stressed areas.”

Beyond that, sources from the Ministry of Housing told La Sexta that Sumar also wants to change the renting model by implementing new tenancy rules: “they are going to establish that a minimum number of years must be spent living in” any property, the source said.

“During those years it will not be possible to sell, except in cases of force majeure. It has to be the habitual residence,” the sources added.

Critics of the Sánchez government argue his housing law has worsened the rental market in Spain by forcing landlords out of the rental sector into the short-term tourist market in order to avoid regulation. 

READ ALSO: The loophole landlords in Spain are using to bypass the 3% rent cap

However the government argues that regional governments, run mostly by the opposition Partido Popular, have failed to effectively implement the measures. Sumar also proposes a solution to this problem: “to condition all public aid for housing destined for the regions to the application of the law to limit rental prices.”

Sumar also suggests it would make indefinite contracts the default contract for all rented housing and to put an end to illegal tourist rentals, among other measures.

Tax and other proposals

The budget proposals also include wide-ranging benefits and tax ideas, including the universal200 per month child-rearing allowance and the creation of a solidarity tax on large inheritances of over €1 million.

It also advocates applying VAT to private education and private health insurance, as well as reducing it on basic products and services such as hairdressers, veterinary centres and nappies.

“It is essential to advance tax justice to finance public policy,” the document states.

READ ALSO: The rules and small print for a rental contract for a room in Spain

SHOW COMMENTS