SHARE
COPY LINK

ELECTIONS

EXPLAINED: The French far-right’s proposal to ban dual nationals from certain jobs

Since the start of the snap election campaign Marine Le Pen's far-right Rassemblement National party has delivered mixed messages on people who hold two nationalities - we take a look at the party's policy on dual nationality, and French citizenship for foreigners.

EXPLAINED: The French far-right's proposal to ban dual nationals from certain jobs
Rassemblement National leader Marine Le Pen and deputy Sebastien Chenu. Photo by Geoffroy VAN DER HASSELT / AFP

At the start of the election campaign, the deputy leader of the far-right Rassemblement National party gave a TV interview in which, among other things, he called on France to end the practice of allowing dual nationality.

He said: “Outside European countries, when you have a nationality, you have one because it says a lot about who you are, what you’re attached to – you can’t be French for some things and Uruguayan for others.”

Sébastien Chenu’s comments caused confusion because although party boss Marine Le Pen had previously had a policy of banning dual nationality, she scrapped this idea in 2022.

Chenu swiftly issued an apology saying that he was mistaken.

However, a few days later French daily Le Monde revealed that the party also has plans to ban dual nationals from working in public sector jobs.

Speaking in the pre-election TV debate on Tuesday night, party leader Jordan Bardella listed the dual-nationals job ban as one of the party’s key priorities in office. 

As part of the party’s ‘French preference’ policy for employment, it also proposes to prohibit “access to jobs in government departments, public companies and legal entities entrusted with a public service mission to people who hold the nationality of another state”.

READ ALSO What is ‘national preference’ and how would it hurt foreigners?

This would include both people who have gained French citizenship through naturalisation and people who have been dual nationals from birth, by virtue of having a non-French parent.

Although the party offers little detail, French media report that it would concern ‘sensitive’ roles within the public sector, with a full list of the jobs affected published by decree (but only after the election).

French media also suggests that the ban would not affect people who have dual nationality with another EU country, although the party has not confirmed this.

Current policy 

At present France has no restrictions on dual nationality – which means that any foreigners who gain French citizenship are not required to give up any other passports that they may hold (unless their home country requires it – for example India requires any of its citizens who gain another nationality to give up their Indian passport).

France is also one of the more generous countries in Europe when it comes to granting citizenship – those applying through residency are only required to have lived in France for five years, while many other European countries require 10 years of residency.

READ ALSO Am I eligible for French citizenship 

Candidates are however required to speak French and to prove their integration into French life via an interview where they can be grilled on anything from the French political system to the language that they speak at home. 

There are no restrictions on employment (or anything else) for dual nationals – certain high-level government posts are restricted to French citizens, but that includes dual nationals.

Once you become French you should be treated by the administration in the same way as someone who has been French from birth.

Rassemblement National policy

In 2017, part of Le Pen’s platform was suppression of dual nationality for non-EU citizens – so for example it would be possible to be a French-German dual national but not to hold both French and American passports.

There are some countries in Europe that have similar policies – for example Austria bans dual nationality for people who have gained Austrian citizenship through naturalisation, although those who have two passports through blood ties can keep them. Germany previously forbade dual nationality for non-EU nationals, although it has recently repealed this ban.

However by the time the 2022 elections came round Le Pen had abandoned the proposal, saying: “I’ve met thousands of people, for example Moroccans who, legally, can’t renounce their nationality because their country forbids it. Honestly, I prefer to put that aside because it’s like putting salt on open wounds.”

Politicians coming up with policies without doing basic research? Never. 

So it seems that at present, RN has no plans to change rules on dual nationals and people would still be able to gain French citizenship and keep their previous nationality.

However, the ‘French preference’ policy discriminates against those who hold dual nationality – outlawing them from taking up public sector jobs.

Bardella also seemed to make a distinction against dual nationals when he said: “French people of foreign origin or nationality have nothing to fear, if they work, pay their taxes, pay their contributions, respect the law…”.

This was later blamed on a slip of the tongue.

When it comes to French citizenship Le Pen said that she would allow it only to people who have “earned it and assimilated” – although she did not specify how this would be different to the current process, which already requires a French test and an interview on French culture for those applying through residency or marriage.

The 2022 immigration law raises the language requirement from B1 to B2 for those applying through residency – further changes could be another hike in the language level required or raising the qualifying period for those applying for residency from five years.

Currently France has one of the most generous residency requirements in Europe, many other countries require 10 years of residency.

You can find the full details of Le Pen’s party’s 2024 manifesto HERE.

READ ALSO What would a far-right prime minister mean for foreigners in France

Member comments

  1. To be fair many countries won’t let you take up certain roles (ie intelligence services) if you are a naturalised citizen – it’s often an unwritten rule but it happens in practice, and even affects those married to overseas nationals.

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

ELECTIONS

French parties in final push for votes ahead of snap elections

France's political forces are making a final bid on Friday for votes in crunch legislative elections that could see the far right take control of the government in a historic first.

French parties in final push for votes ahead of snap elections

The official campaigning period ends at midnight on Friday, followed by a day off on Saturday, during which political activity is forbidden ahead of voting on Sunday. Another week of campaigning will then lead up to the decisive second round on July 7th.

The far-right Rassemblement National (RN) is tipped to win the election, potentially giving the party the post of prime minister for the first time in its history in a tense “cohabitation” with centrist President Emmanuel Macron.

What’s at stake for foreigners in France if far-right Jordan Bardella becomes prime minister?

“Of course, I want to avoid the extremes, especially the far right, being able to win” the ballot, Macron’s Prime Minister Gabriel Attal told broadcaster BFMTV on Friday.

Opinion polls suggest his centrist alliance will come only third behind the RN and a broad but fragile left-wing coalition, the Nouveau Front Populaire (NFP).

The RN party chief, Jordan Bardella, 28, would have a chance to lead a government as prime minister.

But he has insisted he would do so only if his party wins an absolute majority – 289 of the 577 seats in the National Assembly – after the second round.

His party’s path to victory could be blocked if the left and centre-right join forces against the RN in the second round of voting.

Macron has caused controversy in the past two weeks by placing the left and the far-right on the same footing, labelling both “extremes”.

Speaking in Brussels on Thursday, however, he suggested that he would support moderate leftists against the far-right in the second round.

Macron also blasted the “arrogance” of the far right, which had “already allocated all the (government) jobs” before the election and questioned the president’s constitutional role as military commander in chief.

“Who are they to explain what the constitution should say?” he asked.

The RN’s three-time presidential candidate Marine Le Pen had ratcheted up tensions by saying that the president’s commander-in-chief title was purely “honorific”.

In the event of Macron having to share power with an RN-led government, “it’s the prime minister who holds the purse strings”, she warned.

In a televised debate on Thursday night, Attal said that Le Pen’s remarks sent a “very serious message for the security of France.”

Bardella sought to reassure voters about his party’s foreign policy, saying in the debate he would “not let Russian imperialism absorb an allied state like Ukraine”.

He said he was also opposed to sending longer range missiles to Ukraine that could hit Russian territory “and place France and the French in a situation of co-belligerence”.

“My compass is the interest of France and the French,” said Bardella.

Macron has insisted he will serve out the remainder of his second term until it expires in 2027, no matter which party emerges on top in the coming legislative contest.

Le Pen, whom opponents have long accused of having too cosy a relationship with the Kremlin, senses that this could be her best-ever chance to win the Elysée Palace after three previous attempts.

When he called the snap vote after a June 9th European Parliament election drubbing by the RN, Macron had hoped to present voters with a stark choice about whether to hand France to the far right.

An Opinionway poll of 1,058 people published Friday in business daily Les Echos predicted the RN would win 37 percent of the vote, the NFP 28 percent and Macron’s alliance just 20 percent.

In the second round, the RN “can not only envisage a relative majority, but we cannot exclude, far from it, an absolute majority,” Brice Teinturier, deputy director of competing pollster Ipsos, told AFP.

The televised debate, where Attal and Bardella were joined by Socialist leader Olivier Faure, was as ill-tempered as the first such session on Tuesday.

Attal charged that 100 RN candidates standing in the election had made “racist, anti-Semitic and homophobic comments.”

“Everything is false, utterly false,” responded Bardella, who also defended a controversial proposal to bar dual nationals from sensitive state posts.

Underscoring the stakes felt by many in France from ethnic minority backgrounds, French basketball superstar Victor Wembanyama said “for me it is important to take a distance from extremes, which are not the direction to take for a country like ours”.

He joins a host of other French sports, music and acting stars who have spoken out against the far right.

How to follow all the latest French election news in English this weekend

SHOW COMMENTS