SHARE
COPY LINK

ELECTIONS

Why pollsters are finding it hard to predict France’s snap elections

France's usually highly accurate political pollsters face a rare challenge in snap elections called by President Emmanuel Macron, struggling to predict the future shape of the Assemblée nationale.

Why pollsters are finding it hard to predict France's snap elections
Ballots in a ballot box at a polling station in Vanves, a suburb of Paris. Photo by Arnaud FINISTRE / AFP

France’s two-round voting system means that “the parliamentary election is usually difficult to begin with,” said an employee of one major survey firm.

But with new alliances and divisions within parties themselves, “we have no frame of reference now, the deck has been reshuffled,” she added, asking not to be named.

Some pollsters have had to reimburse staff for cancelled or delayed holidays to cope with the extra workload, the person said.

In the French electoral system, voters in the country’s 577 constituencies have a broad choice of candidates in the first round, which is set this time around for June 30th.

The two highest scorers plus any others who win backing from more than 12.5 percent of registered voters then proceed to the second round on July 7th.

If any candidate wins more than 50 percent in the first round then they win the seat without the need for a second round – this is rare in parliamentary elections but it does happen in some areas.

Voters often shift their support between the rounds, often at the behest of preferred candidates who fall short.

That makes prediction far more complex than the one-round proportional representation system in the June 9th European Parliament poll, when pollsters’ forecasts were all close to the final score.

“We’re losing a bit of sleep” ahead of the national ballot, said Jean-Daniel Levy, deputy director at Harris Interactive.

“The parliamentary election is the trickiest to grasp… it’s 577 polls and their local foibles,” he added.

Most opinion surveys are carried out online, with pollsters taking representative samples of over 1,000 people and asking where they live in a bid to smooth out constituency oddities — allowing them to extrapolate to the national level.

On the face of it, voters have a choice between three headline blocs: Macron’s centrists, the far-right Rassemblement National (RN) and the Nouveau Front Populaire (NFP) left-wing alliance.

An Ifop poll published Monday found that around 33 percent of people would vote RN in the first round, with the left at 28 percent and 18 percent for Macron’s bloc.

In fact, “it’s a lot more complicated,” said Mathieu Gallard, research director at Ipsos, pointing for example to the “totally chaotic” situation within the right-wing Les Républicains party (LR).

The LR has imploded, with party chief Eric Ciotti calling for an alliance with the far right while other figures want to maintain their independence or align with Macron.

Such dynamics mean national-level forecasts of votes and seats come with a clear buyer-beware warning.

It is almost impossible to predict this time how voters might behave between the two rounds.

“Mistakes are all but certain and we don’t know in which direction,” said Jerome Sainte-Marie, a former pollster standing for the RN in eastern France.

“The 2022 election showed us that seat projections before the first round are extremely shaky,” agreed Gallard. “It’s only after the first round that we’ll start to have a developing idea of the forces at play.”

Two years ago, surveys overestimated backing for Macron’s camp and underestimated the RN vote.

The party of Marine Le Pen was predicted to win 15 to 35 seats ahead of the first round, then up to 50 ahead of the second.

In the end, they brought in their largest-ever delegation of 89 MPs, overcoming a longstanding struggle for the far right to translate support into seats.

This year, “we’re in a totally unprecedented period, it’s almost impossible to understand what the political landscape will be in a week and a half,” said Hugo Touzet, a sociologist specialising in polls.

“If we do things seriously, the margin of error is plus or minus 80 MPs for each bloc, it’s huge,” he added.

Harris’s Levy told AFP that voters could return a “possible absolute or relative majority for the RN… repeating their voting behaviour at the European Parliament election”.

He sees “a little momentum” for the left that is still “far short of triggering a swing in parliament”.

On Macron’s side, there’s a “burst of mobilisation” that could prevent a re-run of their European rout.

Predictions made after the first-round results at 8pm on June 30th “could quickly go out of date” as voters update their preference before the second round on July 7th.

It could be that having “sent a message, voters don’t want all the power in the hands of the RN”, Levy said.

You can find all the latest election news HERE, or sign up here to receive by email our bi-weekly election breakdown.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

ELECTIONS

Will the far-right get a majority in the French parliament?

With the far-right in the lead after the first round of the snap French elections the big question now is whether they can win a majority in parliament - which gives them the right to nominate the prime minister.

Will the far-right get a majority in the French parliament?

Preliminary results for round one of voting on June 30th show the far-right Rassemblement National (RN) party in the lead with 34.5 percent of the vote, followed by the left alliance Nouveau Front Populaire on 28.1 percent and Emmanuel Macron’s centrist group on 20.8 percent.

Follow the latest on the results HERE.

We now move on to round two – which will give the final results in each of France’s 577 constituencies.

The big question is whether any party or group can reach the magic number of 289 seats, which would give them a majority in the Assemblée nationale (the French parliament).

A party or group that gets 289 seats not only gets to exercise control over votes on legislation, but can also nominate a member of the party to be prime minister.

If a party other than the president’s party has a majority then the prime minister and the president are forced to work together in an easy alliance known as a cohabitiation.

So will the far-right RN win enough seats to get a majority?

First things first – this is all guesswork, we won’t know for certain whether Le Pen and Jordan Bardella’s party will have enough seats for a majority until the results of the second round are in on the evening of Sunday, July 7th.

However the pollsters have been working their magic trying to predict the total seat share from the first round vote and it seems they RN are set to win a huge number of seats. 

Various different polling agencies have different and very wide estimates, but all are saying that the final result for the RN could be close to that key number of 289.

A projection for the Elabe institute for BFMTV, RMC and La Tribune Dimanche put RN and its allies on between 255 and 295 seats.

Early projections from Ipsos suggest that RN and its allies could win between 230 and 280 seats in parliament.

It’s worth noting that given the unpredictability around the second round of voting (see below) France’s official polling watchdog does not endorse the seat projections by the polling companies.

Polls in the run up to the first round suggested the RN would not gain an absolute majority in parliament but wouldn’t be far off.

Second round votes

A big factor in the second round will be the ‘triangulaires’ or areas where the second round has three candidates.

In areas where this happens, it’s possible that some parties will agree to withdraw candidates in order to avoid splitting the vote – negotiations are ongoing in this area but it’s most likely to happen with leftist or centrist candidates.

The intention is to present a common front against the far-right – so if this happens in a significant number of areas it could affect the far-right’s overall seat numbers.

Follow the latest on those negotiations HERE.

Prime minister

If the far-right does gain an overall majority it has the right to nominate a candidate for prime minister and that person will be 28-year-old Jordan Bardella.

He has already said that he will only accept the PM role if his party wins an overall majority.

Although Macron will remain the president, having a parliamentary majority and a prime minister means the far-right will be in a much stronger position to implement some of their flagship policies including a drastic reduction in immigration and the imposing of ‘French preference’ to give precedence to French citizens in employment and housing.

READ ALSO What would a far-right prime minister mean for foreigners in France?

SHOW COMMENTS