SHARE
COPY LINK

PROTESTS

Environmental protesters block French cruise liner port

Environmental activists blocked France's leading cruise liner port in the southern city of Marseille on Saturday to protest against the sea, air and climate pollution generated by the huge vessels.

Environmental protesters block French cruise liner port
Activists from the NGO "Stop croisieres" and "Extinction Rebellion France" hold banners while they block the AIDAstella cruise ship. Photo: CLEMENT MAHOUDEAU/AFP.

About 20 members of Extinction Rebellion and Marseille-based Stop Croisieres (Stop Cruises) made a chain of canoes in the water across the entry to the port, an AFP correspondent reported.

The demonstration forced one ship to turn back at 7:00 am (0500 GMT) and moor further down the coast. Others had to stay in stand-by outside the port until about 9:30 am.

The activists were removed and the port has since reopened, the maritime authorities told AFP.

“Nothing justifies the maintenance of these absurd, energy-intensive and toxic floating cities,” Stop Croisieres said on its website.

“Our air, our seas and our health are not up for negotiation,” it said.

It criticised the noxious heavy fuel oil used by the vessels, the destruction of ocean and coastal wildlife, the ships’ impact on the climate and poor working conditions for employees on board.

The protest prevented the Germany-owned Aidastella, which can carry around 2,000 people, from docking at around 7:00 am.

The Costa Smeralda and the MSC World Europa also had to wait before entering the port.

The MSC World Europa is the sixth largest cruise liner in the world. It can carry 6,000 passengers and has more than 2,600 cabins, as well as 13 restaurants and a shopping centre.

The Cruise Lines International Association condemned the protest as “illegal and dangerous”.

In an email to AFP, it argued the cruise liner industry was pursuing efforts to cut emissions of climate-heating greenhouse gases.

Pollution

Marseille is the centre of a burgeoning cruise ship industry in France.

Between 2022 and 2023, the number of cruise passengers entering the port jumped from 1.5 million to 2.5 million, according to the Marseille tourism observatory.

Advocates of cruise liners argue they provide revenue to stopover ports.

Detractors say the ships encourage passengers to spend their money onboard, not on land, and that the industry promotes competition between reception ports to force down prices.

There have been protests in several European port cities against the damage caused by cruise liners, including in Venice and Amsterdam, which have banished them from docking in the city centre.

Stop Croisieres was set up during the Covid pandemic.

“We saw videos of nature being restored all over France, little birds in towns and other bucolic scenes,” said Andrea, who declined to give her surname for fear of prosecution.

“Yet in some parts of Marseille, the air was even more polluted than before the pandemic because of all the cruise liners forced to stay in port with their engines running.”

In March 2023, residents’ associations in Marseille lodged a legal complaint over ocean traffic pollution in the port area, which regularly exceeded European Union limits.

According to a study by NGO Transport and Environment, cruise ships sailing in European waters in 2022 emitted more than eight million tonnes of carbon dioxide — the equivalent of 50,000 Paris to New York flights.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

FARMING

French farmers plan more roadblocks – but won’t say when

Angry French farmers are paving the way for a new set of protests including blockades and roadblocks, saying that government promises have not been fulfilled

French farmers plan more roadblocks – but won’t say when

Earlier this year, France’s farmers blockaded ports, motorways and – for a short time – the world’s largest wholesale fresh produce market in protest at government and EU policies that, they said, were making their lives impossible.

They won concessions from the government. But, after a poor harvest, they say they’re seeing little improvement in their situation, and feel that promises to make farming more sustainable are not being honoured.

READ ALSO IN PICTURES: French farmers blockade Paris

Jérôme Bayle, who organised the earliest blockades, told Sud Radio on Friday that a new round of protests were in the pipeline pending a meeting with new prime minister Michel Barnier – but added: “We’re not going to give the dates, we need to create a surprise effect.”

He said: “A farmer’s job is not to spend his time blocking roads and inconveniencing people. But at the end of the day, at national level, we’re going to have to build a healthy, sustainable agriculture, with a future.”

A few days earlier, Arnaud Rousseau, president of the Fédération Nationale des Syndicats d’Exploitants Agricoles (FNSEA) told RMC, “the anger has not been answered.”

“For the past year, the change we asked for has not been forthcoming,” he said. “A number of promises made in January have not been met with the expected responses.” 

READ ALSO France seeks to placate farmers as protests flare up again

Summer 2024 has been difficult for farmers, with harvests down because of unusual weather conditions, and a health crisis affecting livestock farming. 

“This cocktail is explosive because farmers have the impression that what they had to say has not been heard,” Rousseau said.

READ ALSO ‘Pitchforks will be out’: French farmers threaten action as union calls for protests

“We were told we’d only have a single administrative control, but the transformations aren’t there. Farmers don’t feel that things have changed”.

He cites several examples, such as the aid owed to farmers, which former Prime Minister Gabriel Attal had promised to pay by March 15th. “I took stock on Wednesday in Vendée, and there are still 150 files that have not been settled. The administrative machinery hasn’t been overhauled, and the appointment we made hasn’t arrived.”

Under these conditions, farmers expect rapid action from Barnier, who is still settling into his role at Matignon. “What counts is what he will do for farmers in the coming months.”

The FNSEA has already put forward a number of proposals, and hopes that the future government will work on a bill with measures concerning agricultural pensions, the recognition of agriculture as being of major general interest, and measures to improve farmers’ incomes.

SHOW COMMENTS