SHARE
COPY LINK

POLITICS

Social Democrats beat far-right AfD in Brandenburg state vote

German Chancellor Olaf Scholz's Social Democrats narrowly beat the far-right AfD in a state election in the formerly communist east on Sunday.

Brandenburg's State Premier and SPD top candidate in the regional elections in Brandenburg, Dietmar Woidke arrives for a television interview after the publication of the exit polls in Potsdam, eastern Germany on September 22, 2024.
Brandenburg's State Premier and SPD top candidate in the regional elections in Brandenburg, Dietmar Woidke arrives for a television interview after the publication of the exit polls in Potsdam, eastern Germany on September 22, 2024. Photo by Tobias SCHWARZ / AFP

Scholz’s centre-left SPD won around 30.9 percent of the vote, gaining a slight lead over the anti-immigration Alternative for Germany (AfD), which scored about 29.2 percent, according to projections by public broadcasters. 

The result offers some respite for Scholz’s embattled coalition government, which has sunk in opinion polls a year ahead of national elections.

The vote in Brandenburg has been closely watched because Scholz’s SPD has ruled there ever since Germany’s 1990 reunification. The chancellor’s own electoral district is in the state capital Potsdam.

The AfD, which rails against asylum-seekers, multiculturalism, Islam and Scholz’s government, had hoped to replicate its recent electoral success in the east

Three weeks ago, it stunned the political establishment by taking first place in a parliamentary vote, for the first time ever, in the eastern state of Thuringia and coming a close second in neighbouring Saxony.

Despite its ballot box success, the AfD is unlikely to take power in any state since all other mainstream parties have so far ruled out entering into a governing alliance with the party.

READ ALSO: 6 articles to help you understand Germany’s eastern state elections

Turnout reaches 74 percent

Brandenburg’s popular SPD state premier Dietmar Woidke had kept his distance during the campaign from his party colleague Scholz.

In office for more than a decade, Woidke had also thrown down a challenge to voters, by telling them he would quit if the AfD wins.

The AfD, which failed in its aim “to send Woidke into retirement”, nonetheless hailed its strong showing.

Party co-leader Tino Chrupalla said it had “taken gold once and silver twice” in three elections in the east this month.

A visibly relieved Woidke basked in the applause from the party faithful, celebrating the close win in a race where just weeks ago his party had trailed the AfD in the opinion polls.

Brandenburg's State Premier and SPD top candidate in the regional elections in Brandenburg, Dietmar Woidke, and his wife Susanne react after the publication of the exit polls at the election party venue of the SPD in Potsdam.

Brandenburg’s State Premier and SPD top candidate in the regional elections in Brandenburg, Dietmar Woidke, and his wife Susanne react after the publication of the exit polls at the election party venue of the SPD in Potsdam. Photo by Tobias SCHWARZ / AFP

The goal, he said, had been to prevent Brandenburg from being marked with a “great, brown stamp”, the colour associated with fascism.

The message appeared to have energised voters, as turnout reached 74 percent.

Another AfD co-leader, Alice Weidel, said it was now clear that overall “we are the strongest force in the east”, a region that still lags behind western Germany in jobs and wealth.

“It’s an important stage, as you’ll see in the federal elections,” she said.

Scholz is unlikely to profit much from the victory, pollster Manfred Guellner told the Tagesspiegel daily, arguing that the election was all about Woidke.

“Woidke has everything that Olaf Scholz lacks: approval, sympathy, a down-to-earth attitude, cohesive strength,” said Guellner. “In this respect, Woidke is the anti-Scholz.”

Der Spiegel magazine agreed. While Scholz “must be pretty relieved” that his party’s success “brings stability”, the chancellor “did not contribute at all to this miracle”, it said.

‘Fear of attacks’

The decade-old AfD, originally a eurosceptic fringe party, has long stoked public fears about irregular migration, especially after a string of recent attacks with suspected Islamist motives.

The AfD’s rhetoric has heaped pressure on Scholz and his governing allies, the Free Democrats and the Greens, an ecologist party that looked set to be booted out of the state legislature.

Co-leader of the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party Alice Weidel looks on during the electoral evening at the State Parliament (Landtag) in Potsdam, in the eastern German state of Brandenburg, on September 22, 2024.

Co-leader of the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party Alice Weidel during the electoral evening at the State Parliament (Landtag) in Potsdam, in the eastern German state of Brandenburg, on September 22, 2024. Photo by RALF HIRSCHBERGER / AFP

Infighting in the national government has seen Scholz’s approval ratings plummet. In contrast defence minister Boris Pistorius, also a Social Democrat, often tops surveys as Germany’s most popular politician.

In the long run-up to national elections in September 2025, the opposition conservatives of the CDU-CSU alliance last week selected their party leader Friedrich Merz as their top candidate.

READ ALSO: Who is the conservative leader hoping to become Germany’s new chancellor?

But the CDU also took a beating in Brandenburg, winning only around 11 percent.

New leftist party

This year has also seen the emergence of a second populist party, the left-wing Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance (BSW), which won around 12 percent in Brandenburg.

Hailing from former East Germany, Wagenknecht is a veteran opposition politician and frequent TV talk show guest who quit the hard-left Die Linke party to form her own movement.

She has described the BSW’s policies as “leftist-conservative” — a blend of economic policies that help workers and the poor and conservative cultural positions including on limiting immigration.

After scoring well in three eastern state elections, Wagenknecht’s party could gain a potential kingmaker role, complicating the task for the other parties who oppose her pro-Russia and anti-NATO stance.

Member comments

  1. One cannot help but notice a longstanding, consistent bias in reporting here. AfD is always “extreme” or “far” right. Yet Die Linke, which is the successor party to the communist SED, the state party of the DDR, is never described in similarly indicting terms, such as “extreme Left.”

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

POLITICS

Who are the winners and losers of Germany’s key state election in Brandenburg?

As the Social Democrats have managed to edge ahead of the AfD in the Brandenburg vote, we look at the big winners and losers and what happens next.

Who are the winners and losers of Germany's key state election in Brandenburg?

It’s been a busy month for politics in Germany, with elections in the states of Thuringia, Saxony and Brandenburg. 

On Sunday, Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s Social Democrats (SPD) scored a somewhat unexpected victory in Brandenburg, the state surrounding Berlin.

The centre-left SPD won around 30.9 percent of the vote, gaining a slight lead over the anti-immigration Alternative for Germany (AfD), which scored about 29.2 percent, according to projections by public broadcasters. 

Meanwhile, new left-wing populist party, the Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance (BSW) landed in third place with about 13.5 percent of the vote and the Christian Democrats (CDU) took 12.1 percent.

With only 4.1 percent of the vote, the Greens missed the 5 percent threshold to make it into parliament. Other parties to miss the threshold include the Free Democrats (FDP) and Die Linke (The Left). In fact the FDP got less than 1 percent of the vote.

READ ALSO: 6 articles to help you understand Germany’s eastern state elections

The Social Democrats won. Why?

It’s a good question considering the current political climate. In Germany-wide polls, support for the SPD – who are currently leading the so-called ‘traffic light’ coalition in the federal government with the Greens and the Free Democrats (FDP) – has dropped significantly. A recent nationwide poll put the SPD on 15 percent, behind the CDU/CSU’s 32 percent and the AfD’s 20 percent. 

Yet the SPD did gather the most votes at the ballot box in Brandenburg. Experts say this that Chancellor Olaf Scholz can’t take credit for this achievement – even though his own electoral district is in the state capital of Potsdam. 

The SPD has led the government in Brandenburg since Germany’s reunification in 1990, so the state is a stronghold. Also state premier Dietmar Woidke is popular among locals. 

In office for more than a decade, Woidke issued a dramatic challenge to voters by telling them he would quit if the AfD wins. It clearly paid off. In a survey conducted just before the vote, 65 percent said they considered him to be a good leader, and his support comes from across the board – with almost 30 percent of AfD supporters agreeing. 

Brandenburg's State Premier and SPD top candidate in the regional elections in Brandenburg, Dietmar Woidke arrives for a television interview after the publication of the exit polls in Potsdam, eastern Germany on September 22, 2024.

Brandenburg’s State Premier and SPD top candidate in the regional elections in Brandenburg, Dietmar Woidke arrives for a television interview after the publication of the exit polls in Potsdam, eastern Germany on September 22, 2024. Photo by Tobias SCHWARZ / AFP

Woidke prefers to keep his distance from the federal stage – and did not have Scholz involved in his campaign. 

Others said the result was a reaction to the far-right AfD winning the vote in the state of Thuringia. German daily Bild said political topics such as climate change or migration policy were not the deciding factor in this election. 

“When the SPD won the state elections in Brandenburg, concerns about an AfD triumph and the Woidke factor overshadowed all factual issues,” said the tabloid. 

READ ALSO: ‘Political earthquake’ – What the far-right AfD state election win means for Germany 

The AfD came second. Is it a victory for them?

Yes, they also see themselves as winners. Although they failed to “send Woidke into retirement” as they had said threatened to do, the party made strong gains. 

It has managed to win a so-called blocking minority – for the second time after its success in Thuringia three weeks ago. With 30 out of 88 seats, it now has more than a third of the spots, and can therefore prevent decisions that require a two-thirds majority. This applies, for instance, to the election of constitutional judges and constitutional amendments. This gives the AfD considerable influence, even though no other party wants to govern with it.

Co-leaders of Germany's far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party Tino Chrupalla and Alice Weidel and AfD top candidate for the regional elections in Brandenburg, Hans-Christoph Berndt.

Co-leaders of Germany’s far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party Tino Chrupalla and Alice Weidel and AfD top candidate for the regional elections in Brandenburg, Hans-Christoph Berndt. Photo by John MACDOUGALL / AFP

The AfD, which takes a hard-line stance against asylum-seekers, multiculturalism, Islam and ‘mainstream party’ policies, stunned the country a few weeks ago by winning for the first time ever in a state election in Thuringia, and coming a close second in neighbouring Saxony.

Party co-leader Tino Chrupalla said it had “taken gold once and silver twice” in three elections in the east this month.

Despite its ballot box success, the AfD is unlikely to take power in any state since all other mainstream parties have so far ruled out entering into a governing alliance with the party.

The party was also hitting headlines for the wrong reasons after a deportation song was played at their election party.

To the tune of the song ‘Das geht ab’ by the the band Die Atzen, several supporters were seen singing a song about deporting immigrants. 

“Hey, that’s going down, We’ll deport them all, deport them all”, they sang in German, while holding up the slogan “Deport millions”.

The scene was filmed by journalists causing widespread outrage online. 

Earlier this year, it was discovered that AfD members and others talked about a concept called ‘remigration’ – which would involve the mass deportation of immigrants and “non-assimilated citizens” from Germany – in the event of the party coming to power. The AfD distanced itself from the remigration plan at the time, but this incident raises further questions. 

Woidke said the AfD election result in Brandenburg was a “huge alarm signal for all of us, for all democrats and for all those who stand for freedom, open and tolerance”.

READ ALSO: ‘I’m worried for my kids’: Foreigners in Germany fearful over rise of far-right

Who are the losers?

The Free Democrats are the big ones. With just 0.8 percent of the vote, the liberals suffered a heavy defeat as they did in Saxony and Thuringia. 

It is sending shockwaves to the government in Berlin – and may break the coalition earlier than the next planned federal election in autumn 2025. 

FDP headquarters say the ‘traffic light’ government is damaging their party. The coalition parties have been at loggerheads for months over several issues such as migration policy, the budget and taxes.

A crisis meeting was being held on Monday morning among leaders of the party. 

Some figures in the FDP are spelling out how serious it is. FDP General Secretary Bijan Djir-Sarai gave the impression to German broadcaster ARD that he was already done with the coalition, saying it will be an “autumn of decisions”.

Meanwhile, FDP deputy leader Wolfgang Kubicki seemed to issue an ultimatum on Welt: “Either we actually manage to find a sensible common denominator here in the next 14 days, three weeks, or it no longer makes sense for the Free Democrats to continue participating in this coalition.”

The Greens also had a tough night. Party leader Ricarda Lang said it was a negative trend and “we will fight our way out of it together”. She said that lost trust among voters had to be regained. 

How easy will it be to form a government in Brandenburg?

Like Saxony and Thuringia, politicians in Brandenburg will face a difficult time forming a government. Although the SPD is the strongest force, their previous coalition partners, the CDU and the Greens, lost ground significantly.

Woidke said he will first hold talks with his previous government partner, the CDU. However, this two-party alliance lacks a majority. 

As all parties in Germany to refuse to work with the AfD, Woidke would only have a majority with the CDU and the Sahra Wagenknecht (BSW) alliance.

The BSW’s co-leader Amira Mohamed Ali said the party had an “open mind” to talking with the parties.

Political researcher Thorsten Faas highlighted the tricky situation ahead. “None of this is tried and tested,” he told DPA. “There is no guarantee that this will be a smoothly functioning coalition.”

SHOW COMMENTS